News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alda: A music programming language by coldtea on Sunday September 06, 2015 @04:16PM (#10178861)
>Therefore it is music notation

Only in that its a notation for music ENTRY. Not meant to be used in the same way as the traditional music notation that you wrote about ("When I look at a traditional score I see and hear the music in my mind pretty much instantly").

That is, it's not meant to be read by players as is, which is the whole point of traditional music notation. It has a very specific, computer related role -- it's the equivalent of clicking on buttons in some GUI based notation software.

Your subsequent comment makes it evident that you haven't gotten what this is meant for:

>For example, one of the cases discussed in the article is classical music. I cannot imagine anyone capable of creating scores for orchestras (or even single instruments) not having years of traditional musical training, which would include reading and writing conventional scores.

This is NOT meant as a replacement for classic notation -- to relieve people from having to read and write it. It's not meant to be printed and handed to musicians as is.

This is for people (including people who KNOW notation), to enter that data in a textual, CLI way, instead of clicking the mouse or doing step entry in Finale. Or, similar to how people enter notes in "trackers".

>That would be silly. My proposal is that the evolution of our brain over millions of years provides us with unique image recognition, pattern matching and association capabilities --that evolved for other reasons, not for music-- that happen to result in us being really good at symbolic notation.

That doesn't make classical notation any particular fit for our brains. It was developed ad hoc, neither organically nor after actual experiment and there's no study proving it's "best" music notation we can have. But that's another story, as, again, this tool is not meant to replace traditional music notation.

There are no comments on this comment yet.