News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alda: A music programming language by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday September 06, 2015 @02:52PM (#10178581)
>It's an entry method for writing MIDI.

I'd suggest no one needs yet another text-to-MIDI system.

There are plenty of existing methods that do the job just fine - from live recording, to step entry, to any of the hundred or so text-based systems that have been (re)invented since the 1950s. (And which hardly anyone uses, because for most people - even most programmers - ASCII turns out to be a really clumsy and difficult way to write a non-trivial score.)

Re:Alda: A music programming language by coldtea on Sunday September 06, 2015 @04:20PM (#10178872)
>I'd suggest no one needs yet another text-to-MIDI system.

Well, I need one. What are you gonna do about it?

>And which hardly anyone uses, because for most people - even most programmers - ASCII turns out to be a really clumsy and difficult way to write a non-trivial score.

Check again. There are large communities around cli tools for music, especially in electronic and experiemental scenes.

Re:Alda: A music programming language by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday September 06, 2015 @06:28PM (#10179323)
>What are you gonna do about it?

Suggest you look at abc2MIDI, which has been around since 2002:

http://abc.sourceforge.net/abcMIDI/original/README.txt

>There are large communities around cli tools for music,

Actually there aren't. The biggest community is around Max, with PD a close second, and both are dataflow languages, not clis, although they have code affordances.

Most musicians don't get on with cli's at all. (I know this because I've sometimes tried to teach them.) Judging by mailing list volumes, actual volunteer user numbers - i.e. excluding students who have to learn them on courses before giving them up - are in the hundreds of users for each of the most popular clis, as a world wide total.

Trackers are a lot more popular - but they're a different subculture.

In any case, ALDA is barely a cli for music - it's a very simple ASCII music specification with a bare bones GM runtime, and it has some important features missing. (n-tuplets or chord symbols or key signatures?)

For a non-trivial cli look at Common Music, Csound, SuperCollider, Overtone (which runs on Clojure), ChucK, Impromptu, or even Sonic Pi, all of which do quite a bit more.