Previously, every distro built their own init systems and core tools to manage services, leading to meaningless differences in an area where heterogeneity is not a benefit, but hinders progress instead.
I don't really have an opinion one way or the other about the rest of the project's tools like networkd or the dhcp server and what have they, but having a working service manager out of the box (which means it actually gets used by default!) has already made my life easier compared to the old sysvinit thing that couldn't even reliably tell you if your services were running or not, never mind anything more advanced.
There's your problem. You don't even have any defined scope. A "coherent, modern core userland" doesn't actually mean anything concrete - it covers enormous ground that no single package can obey.
Modern service managers are plentiful - nosh, s6 and perp probably being the most promising.
The "old sysvinit thing" has been replaced many times for over 15 years by now. Just because you didn't notice, well, that's your problem.
I found it rather enlightening and found myself agreeing with pretty much everything. Trying to argue for or against systemd is a waste of time, so I will stop.
All the time spent debating would likely be better used just spreading knowledge about your preferred methods so that people can make informed choices when solving their own problems.
Trying to argue for or against systemd is a waste of time, so I will stop.
I have to agree.
You're saying it as if there aren't already plenty of them.