News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by api on Friday September 04, 2015 @02:36PM (#10172120)
I've been in favor of this for a long time, but I do have a more nuanced opinion in that I'm not sure if it's "time" yet.

IMHO we're getting there, and when the (very likely) big wave of automation hits it will be time. The true automation wave has not happened yet, and when it hits it will make the outsourcing wave look like a minor disruption to the employment market. I fully expect that by the year 2100 most non-skilled labor will be obsolete.

--

Edit:

There's one more "elephant in the living room" that I'd like to bring up in this thread before I'm outta here. I'll leave it here at the root since it's part of the core point I was making. Few bring up this fact since it leads to areas that many consider non-PC or impolite to discuss.

The average IQ is 100, and intelligence and other abilities are normally distributed within the population.

This is pretty much fixed on short-term human timescales unless we can widely deploy genetic engineering and brain-augmentation. Not only are these things massively hard -- probably harder than any of the crazy automation anyone is predicting -- but they're also going to face intense opposition on both religious and secular-ideological grounds. If you think the furor over GMO foods is excessive and irrational, imagine the furor over GMO humans.

It's also likely that those with the strongest opposition to genetic enhancement (on largely superstitious grounds) would be precisely those for whom it would be most beneficial. Conversely, those most enthusiastic to adopt it would be those who don't need it. As a result it would probably accelerate the trend I'm discussing here.

This means that if automation and other factors are constantly conspiring to increase the median skill level requirements of labor, eventually significant portions of humanity are simply going to fall off a cliff where the economic value of their labor becomes zero. From a purely economic point of view these are now worthless human beings. It doesn't matter if labor supply exceeds demand if the labor available to fill that demand can't do the work.

As automation gets better, this cliff will move up the bell curve. As it does, then due to the shape of a bell curve the number of people thus affected will increase exponentially. This is a recipe for blood in the streets -- and for totalitarianism as a response.

So we have a choice.

Option #1: consign those who fall off the edge to poverty and wall them off in ghettoes, and implement a totalitarian political regime with total surveillance of the entire population to deal with the perpetual undercurrent of crime and terrorism that this will create. The result basically looks like a B-grade cyberpunk film.

Option #2: admit to ourselves that we are entering a post-capitalist early-post-scarcity phase of development and implement some level of basic income.

I'd go with option #2. Not only is it better for humanity at large, it's also better for me as I don't fancy living world #1 even if I did get to live in one of the posh totalitarian enclaves.

Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by harryh on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:05PM (#10172250)
If you look at what most people were doing in 1930 most of those jobs are obsolete. And yet most people are still working. I'd be pretty surprised if 2015-2100 turns out to be much different from 1930 - 2015.
Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by dionidium on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:14PM (#10172296)
That assumes that the automation trends of the next 100 years are going to look anything at all like the automation trends of the last 100 years. I don't think that's likely due to pretty obvious technological multipliers. Progress isn't linear.

Additionally, I think if you spend much time around the working classes, even today, you'll find that they're living in a world that's leaving them behind in a way that simply wasn't true even 30 years ago.

Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by dionidium on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:20PM (#10172339)
Also, "most people are still working" is increasingly less true:

* http://www.forbes.com/sites/toddganos/2012/11/03/what-is-rea...

Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by harryh on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:22PM (#10172357)
A significantly greater percentage of the working age population is working at a job today than 85 years ago.
Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by dionidium on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:27PM (#10172389)
Yes, that's true, but that's almost certainly because more women work now than ever did before. That's a one-time (enormous) increase, but there's no reason to believe it's an indication of a longer-term trend. In fact, the data show otherwise.

You can play around with the data here:

* http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS12300000

Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by harryh on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:30PM (#10172398)
I am unmoved by the relatively tiny short term movements you are referring to. Basically all you have shown is that we had a relatively large recession in 2007-08.
Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by api on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:37PM (#10172452)
The past doesn't necessarily predict the future. I really suspect that it might end up being different this time.

My working hypothesis is that software-defined Turing-complete automation is qualitatively different from special-case automation. It permits the rapid reconfiguration of general purpose machines with software, which is cheap and fast to produce in comparison with pretty much any physical system. Combined with simulation it allows for very rapid iteration.

You can in many cases effectively design something and then just hit 'print.' Some human intervention and assembly and some custom work is usually required, but the quantity is far lower and the skill level far higher than in the past. In the end you need a small number of highly skilled employees, not a large number of low-skill ones. The conventional 'worker' is obsolete.

Compare one-off factory tooling set for stamping out one part with a 3d printer, for example. The 3d printer is what the future looks like.

The alternative to a universal basic income here would be something like the world depicted in The Hunger Games series -- tiny super-rich walled totalitarian city-states presiding over a majority that has regressed to 19th century or prior standards of living. I'd personally consider this to be a new dark age.

Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by harryh on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:39PM (#10172464)
Yes, perhaps THIS TIME IT'S DIFFERENT. Perhaps.

I'm just saying I'd be surprised.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by api on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:48PM (#10172516)
If it were possible to predict the future on the basis of the past, everyone would always make money in the stock market.
Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by harryh on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:52PM (#10172543)
Over the long run most people have always made money in the stock market.
Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by xrange on Friday September 04, 2015 @07:31PM (#10173287)
Are you making the simple claim that, over say a 30 year period, certain broad stock market indexes ended higher than they started? Or are you making a much more interesting claim? I'd like to see the data set for that if you can point me in the right direction.
Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by harryh on Friday September 04, 2015 @07:41PM (#10173306)
I'm making the simple claim.
Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by afterburner on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:09PM (#10172270)
This ain't your grand-daddy's automation.
Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by astrocat on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:14PM (#10172292)
What I think what most people count on is the inanely fast ACCELERATION of technological progress. The amount of advancement between 1930 and 2015 will be orders of magnitude less than 2015-2100.
Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by ekr on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:51PM (#10172538)
Why do you say that? I think the technological progress will continue to grow exponentially. There are more researchers now than at any point in human history. The economic incentives are still at least as big (relatively speaking).

At the moment there are many industries with great potential for applying machine learning and various other automation techniques.

And considering that many leading AI scientists are expecting smarter-than-human AI within this century (or the start of the next one), I certainly fail to see your point.

Anyway, there is still a lot of room for exponential growth of human knowledge, in a lot of fields.

Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by chucksmash on Friday September 04, 2015 @06:49PM (#10173204)
I think you misread what he said.
Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by fweespeech on Friday September 04, 2015 @02:57PM (#10172217)
As interesting as it would be to have this in the near future, I'd agree with you.

We would need a semi-permanent 16%+ U6 unemployment before its likely tho. As long as ~90% of the people who want full time jobs can find full time jobs, there simply isn't going to be enough momentum for it.

When automation cuts out the bottom 10% or so of the employment market is when it'd happen.

Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by ThrustVectoring on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:08PM (#10172261)
I'd like to mention that disability rates are another good measure for what you're looking for, since things like "local lumber mill closes, former employees aren't educated enough to get a job afterwards" cause people to go on disability benefits.
Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by phenylene on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:32PM (#10172414)
And likely most skilled labor as well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Pq-S557XQU (Humans Need Not Apply)
Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by api on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:46PM (#10172505)
Personally I think the first "white collar" casualty of automation will be law.

90+% of law involves things like contract law and analysis of legal documents. All of that can be replaced by natural language processing, machine learning, etc. I envision "contract compilers" that produce contracts based on compact specs and other things in the near term (5-10 years out) followed by total replacement of most lower-level legal work with AI/ML in the 15-30 year time frame.

In the end you will still have lawyers, but only to appear in courtrooms and do very high skill specialized legal analysis that involves a lot of conceptual thought. That will be a much smaller number of people than are employed in law today.

That's a lot of well-paying jobs that are going to vaporize.

Re:Citi's Chief Economist Recommends a Universal Basic Income by fnordfnordfnord on Friday September 04, 2015 @03:37PM (#10172447)
>and when the (very likely) big wave of automation hits it will be time.

No it will be late. Now is a good time.