News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google self-driving car pioneer wants to teach people how... by sandworm101 on Friday September 04, 2015 @12:09PM (#10171325)
Arrogant, as is typical of those with a financial stake in a particular version of progress. This guy is under the belief that his version of the future will happen and that it is his job to help others realise that truth. Technological progress may be inevitable, but that progress envisioned by any particular person is not.

Nanodegrees may seem a good idea, and they no doubt make sense financially to google, but that does not make them inevitable. People have been attending today's traditional schools since long before the Aztecs were even a thing (Cambridge 1200s). There is wisdom in those years. It may be time to change that wisdom, but it won't happen within a generation.

Self-driving cars seem likely but are not inevitable. All sorts of safety-enhancing technologies are dropped for apparently irrelevant reasons. Why do we sell cars that can break speed limits? Why do school buses not have seat belts? Why do planes still have error-prone pilots? Why are alcohol and cigarettes still a thing? Each of those have at some point been challenged by technological progressives who though their version of the future was unavoidable. Each was proven wrong. Only the arrogant assume the future.

fyi, anyone who thinks driverless cars are inevitable should look at the futurama exhibit of 1939. We were then going to have them by 1960. Then it was ford. Now it is google. I'll believe it when I see it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Futurama_%28New_York_World%27s...

Re:Google self-driving car pioneer wants to teach people how... by moe on Friday September 04, 2015 @12:42PM (#10171510)
Self-driving cars seem likely but are not inevitable.

Yes they are inevitable.

All sorts of safety-enhancing technologies are dropped

Self-driving cars are not only a "safety-enhancing technology".

First and foremost they are a money-saving technology.

Over 4 million people are employed in the USA transportation industry[1]. 1.7 million of them are truck drivers[2].

Global logistics companies will save billions of dollars per year by upgrading their fleets to self-driving vehicles.

[1] http://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_table_201.htm

[2] http://www.bls.gov/ooh/transportation-and-material-moving/he...

Re:Google self-driving car pioneer wants to teach people how... by sandworm101 on Friday September 04, 2015 @12:46PM (#10171529)
My point: There are often seemingly irrational reasons why new technologies are not adopted. One can make all rational arguments only to have them fall down when it comes to implementation. It is arrogant to assume that one today can perfectly predict technology tomorrow. (I say perfectly because the OP references only a narrow range of self-drive tech, not acknowledging all the other options.)
Re:Google self-driving car pioneer wants to teach people how... by davidcgl on Friday September 04, 2015 @01:10PM (#10171672)
Nanodegrees may seem a good idea, and they no doubt make sense financially to google

Google doesn't own Udacity.

Re:Google self-driving car pioneer wants to teach people how... by sandworm101 on Friday September 04, 2015 @01:26PM (#10171767)
Yes but Google does higher lots of young people. They would rather higher kids not saddled by debt. Recent grads without debts will settle for lower salaries than those who need to pay down massive student loans.

As a general rule, industry prefers narrowly-targeted education for skilled/unskilled workers. But when it comes to managers those four/six/eight-year degrees from centuries-old universities are all important. You don't see many executives without degrees. Founders may forgo education, but not so much the people they higher to run things.