why would that matter at all?
Whereas a park, and a café near it, are usually much more quiet, slow-going. People expect to be able to slow down and relax. In a café, there is no constant flow of customers, so the owner doesn't have the incentive to kick you out as soon as possible.
Not all gelling happens in bars or cafes, but I do think they have a great correlation to great discoveries. In fact, I wonder what the actual data says? What does HN think are good metrics to measure this? Proximity to lab benches, cost of drinks, variety of foodstuffs, size of the shop?
Also, I wonder what the introduction of legal marijuana to those states will do to their use of 'other' spaces and areas that you can run into and talk with other researchers. Perhaps an alternative to stimulants and depressants, here being a mild hallucinogen with pot, will uncover new thoughts and ideas to benefit research.
I'd argue that in the US, no one does common spaces like a top-tier school.
One of the many reasons the residential nature of education matters and isn't obsoleted by MOOCs.
The architecture of Stanford Bio-X's Clark Center (https://biox.stanford.edu/about/clark-center) targeted spontaneous meetings and discussion. There's a coffee shop on the third floor and wide open-air stairs in case you bump into someone.
I think all of human society could benefit from that. Human spaces should be common by default. Why not?
Perhaps it would have worked before smartphones, but I don't think it will any longer.
These common and fertile space would allow for collision of ideas to take place and help new innovations emerge.
Much like the english tea houses of the renaissance, Universities need these spaces to help transform ideas and research work into commercial success stories that would have a global and positive impact on humanity.
Author Steven Johnson: 'Where good ideas come from' - http://www.ted.com/talks/steven_johnson_where_good_ideas_com...
Note: For the sake of innovation, I very much support Beer Gardens and I hope it gets funded centrally in every University ~_~