News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by rayiner on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @03:15PM (#10161357)
> But just because I agree to let Google read my location to send me traffic warnings before heading out to work doesn't mean I want the FBI to grab that data without my knowledge so they can determine if I might be a troublemaker

Constitutionally, privacy is a pretty cut-and-dry concept. Information is either private or not. Private information isn't "information I don't want the government to have" it's "information I don't want anyone else to have."

I'm not saying we couldn't restructure the law to express what you're talking about. But it's not just a matter of extending our existing principles to this new situation. You're throwing the concept of "privacy" on its head by saying that you have this information that's "private" but that at the same time some third-party entity (and its employees) actively sifts through to target advertising to you.

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by LordKano on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @03:31PM (#10161428)
Constitutionally, privacy is a pretty cut-and-dry concept. Private information isn't "information I don't want the government to have" it's "information I don't want anyone else to have."

You are incorrect. Your line of thinking runs in direct opposition to Roe V. Wade.

You can share information with your doctor that you specifically do not want the government to have. There's nothing special about doctors, in a constitutional sense. They are a third party providing a service and it is most certainly possible to have shared information with a third party that is still private.

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by rayiner on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @03:37PM (#10161451)
I'm talking about "privacy" in the 4th amendment sense.

The Griswold "privacy" line of cases is pretty much totally inapplicable outside the reproduction/sexual activity/family planning context, largely because they conjure up a "right to privacy" that doesn't really exist in the Constitution.

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by ytpete on Thursday September 03, 2015 @02:52AM (#10163639)
I'm still not sure about your claim that private information consists _only_ of "information I don't want anyone else to have."

You can share information with another trusted party and still have an expectation of privacy (such that the government needs a warrant to compel access to that information). Conversely, you can have information that you don't share with another living soul, and the government can also compel access to that information - e.g. a warrant to search your private belongings. The standard for how the government can access your information doesn't automatically change depending on whether you've shared it with 0 or > 0 people.

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by wtbob on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @03:47PM (#10161496)
> You can share information with your doctor that you specifically do not want the government to have.

Sure, you can—and your doctor will reveal that information to the government if required to do so by mandatory-reporting laws.

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by thephyber on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @09:08PM (#10162863)
Confirmed, (although there may be state law protections, depending on the state). There are similar issues with attorney, accountant, priest, psychotherapist, etc.[1]

Spousal privilege is US federal common law and is complicated because many states have laws that either support or override the federal version.[2]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privilege_%28evidence%29 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spousal_privilege#Communicatio...

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by bad_user on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @03:53PM (#10161521)
You're talking about secrecy, privacy is not secrecy and I don't think you understand what privacy is.

Are you a homosexual or a transgender? Did you ever have an extramarital affair? Do you have HIV, or diabetes? Do you have a criminal record? Are you a muslim or a jew? Have you been abused as a child? Do you have a history of drug usage? Are you in a lower caste? Are you a war veteran? Have you ever spoken against your government to your peers? Have you ever gotten drunk at parties? If you have kids, have you ever taken pictures of them naked?

Depending on context, like the community you leave in, or the mood of your government, there is plenty of criteria for discrimination. In the right context, some of these can get you fired, some can get you killed.

And privacy is not secrecy, but rather the right to not be monitored. By not being monitored, even though you cannot hide your identity, you can control what facets of yourself people see. Privacy is about having control. On the other hand by being monitored, you're on file and likely to get fucked in the future by traits that today may be innocuous, as history shows. And you can also be blackmailed. And skipping the doomsday scenarios, most government institutions are filled with incompetents and do you really, really trust those incompetents to handle that data? I could tell you stories.

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by harryh on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @04:28PM (#10161698)
All of the things you said are interesting but have little to do with the privacy protections in the US Constitution.
Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by selimthegrim on Sunday September 06, 2015 @06:55PM (#10179411)
And which amendment would those privacy protections be located in?
Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by dragontamer on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @05:41PM (#10162079)
> Constitutionally, privacy is a pretty cut-and-dry concept.

That's true. Privacy is anything you kept on your own person or in your own property.

Emails however, are stored on another person's computer and therefore have no expectation of privacy. (some 1980s case IIRC).

Constitutionally, privacy is a cut-and-dry concept for the 1800s when the Bill of Rights were written. The fact of the matter is, the people who wrote the Constitution had no concept of "Cloud Computing" or "Computing" in general.

So it is up to the job of today's Politicians and Judges to figure out what to do in these cases. And that isn't a very easy job to do.

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by SilasX on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @07:48PM (#10162648)
Mails are stored in another person's truck, and yet privacy applies.
Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by dragontamer on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @09:54PM (#10162996)
Unfortunately, when in 1980s when the last Federal Cast happened, Emails were stored on your personal computer inside of your house.

POP was the primary protocol back then, not IMAP. IMAP wasn't invented yet. Therefore, the law lags and even today in 2015, the laws are being used as if emails are stored on personal computers.

Which means Emails are considered "abandoned property" if left on an external computer for more than 6 months. Abandoned Property is not subject to privacy.

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by dcohenp on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @11:49PM (#10163253)
Man, I just spent like 5 minutes looking up "Federal Cast", since it sounded fascinating. Then I just realized, maybe you meant "Federal Case"?
Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by dragontamer on Thursday September 03, 2015 @11:28AM (#10165467)
Crap, too late to edit now. Lol. Sorry about that.
Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by losvedir on Thursday September 03, 2015 @01:11AM (#10163432)
Wow, I had no idea this was the case. Thanks for sharing. I seem to remember that you're a lawyer so I'll have to assume you know what you're talking about. :)

> some third-party entity (and its employees) actively sifts through

Just to be clear, is this condition important to your statement? That is, can you store information with a third-party entity with the assumption that it's constitutionally "private" there if you don't let them sift through it? Say, a bank safe deposit box, or some sort of encrypted enterprise crowd storage, or cperciva's tarsnap?

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by soylentcola on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @04:32PM (#10161730)
I admit my post was more a personal complaint/rant than a legal argument. I guess my concern isn't so much about privacy as it is about the ability (or inability) to decide on at least a general level where to send information.

Put way-too-simplisticly, if someone said to me:

"Would you let my widget track where you drive in exchange for a discount on fuel based on mileage?" Maybe I would say yes. Maybe I would say no.

How about if the offer also said that "the way we pay for this is by scanning the data we collect. That way we can sell ad space to businesses near your common driving areas. They never get your actual data but a shop on your morning commute will pay us to show their ads to people that may pass by." Maybe I would still agree. Or maybe I'd think, "eh....I dunno. Raw data for discounts is one thing but analyzing it for third parties seems sketchy." Again, my choice in general even if I don't ever know the exact workings of the software and transactions or any of the third party businesses buying ad space.

I think of it more like contract law and knowing (at least broadly) what you're agreeing to before you sign.

To continue this ludicrously oversimplified example, let's say I agree to the terms because on one hand, all this targeted advertising seems a little tacky or creepy but on the other hand, it really does beat getting blasted with ads for stores in other towns or items I'd never buy. Plus hey...the discounts on gas mean I'm spending $50 less every month!

Well, without my knowledge, the local Drug Enforcement Agency has decided that the best way to stop trafficking is to either secretly demand all the data collected by this ads-for-fuel service or just install some dodgy new data collection towers that connect to the tracking widget and intercept it all without anyone's knowledge.

That is the point where I have a problem. It's not that I expect complete privacy in public. If law enforcement wants to get a warrant to track my car because they think I'm a criminal suspect, that's something that can happen. But to demand (or just take) mass amounts of data that was only volunteered for other uses is just not cool.

Maybe my animosity comes from thinking that if the state wants all of this info, they ought to develop their own ways of getting it, rather than just taking advantage of legit services that people choose to use. Or maybe if they just came out and said "we're putting a tracker on everyone's car" people would go apeshit.

It's like if you can't convince everyone to submit to tracking by the state/law enforcement, just wait until someone else develops a service everyone wants to sign up for, then demand or steal their data.

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by rayiner on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @05:17PM (#10161942)
> I admit my post was more a personal complaint/rant than a legal argument. I guess my concern isn't so much about privacy as it is about the ability (or inability) to decide on at least a general level where to send information.

Just to clarify, I'm not trying to make it into a legal argument. I think your point is well-taken and widely shared. I'm trying to explain what forces are in play and why it's so hard to make progress on what is a pretty prevalent vision of privacy in the tech community. It's not just a tweek, we're talking about retooling some pretty fundamental assumptions about the powers of government.

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by jack9 on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @03:34PM (#10161436)
> Constitutionally, privacy is a pretty cut-and-dry concept

You clearly don't understand the US Constitution or existing US law. Saying it's cut-and-dry doesn't make it so.

> Information is either private or not

I'm sorry, I made a mistake. You don't understand privacy as a concept at all. Privacy is about access controls.

What's more all this frothing about privacy is not the issue under consideration. The issue is about extranational data being subject to US law because the legal entity in control of the data, is a US company. Other countries have similar requirements (Want to run a cloud service in China? Set up shop in a chinese data center, no AWS for you), and it makes sense to me as a nationalistic interest. What's more, you have these companies deflecting HARD "timeless values should endure. Privacy is a timeless value" which is a red flag. I don't care that the French have a firm grasp of privacy, this is a US issue. These companies are free to leave the US if they really believe this is wrong (they wont).

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by apu on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @05:15PM (#10161932)
Please be civil.

BTW, the person you're replying to is a lawyer. Are you?

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by cthalupa on Thursday September 03, 2015 @03:42AM (#10163742)
>BTW, the person you're replying to is a lawyer. Are you?

I'm a unix systems administrator. That doesn't mean everything I say about unix systems is right.

I'm not saying that said lawyer is incorrect about anything, because I honestly have no idea - but if we're asking people to be civil, we should also probably refrain from logical fallacies and defend him on the merit of his statement, and not his job title.