News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A neuroscientist who believes addiction is not a disease by wpietri on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @02:43PM (#10161194)
I think we broadly agree.

What I'm pointing at is that the GAD criteria, as with the criteria for many diseases, is not, "Hey patient, is this a problem for you?" It's a judgment by the clinician over whether the impairment is significant. That's generally fine with wise clinical judgment and clear signals of illness. (E.g., there's little dispute over whether a broken leg is a problem.) But I think there are issues when things are only a problem for other people, or only a problem because other people are different. There I think applying the disease model can be mixed, both helpful (when it allows addicts to get the support they need) and harmful (when different people are treated as broken).

See, for example, the literature on medicalization of deviance: https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=deviance+and+medicaliza...

This is especially problematic in the US because medicalization is not just socially convenient, but frequently profitable.

I also agree that people casually using diagnostic language is a problem. Indeed, I think it's closely related to the problem that concerns me, where people take traits that are helpful in some contexts and harmful in others and declare them to be diseases.

There are no comments on this comment yet.