News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by mindslight on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @01:59PM (#10160942)
It seems like you're perfectly content for Googappazon to turn around and voluntarily sell "your" data to governments.

Given that it's really their data about you, they don't even need to disclose this in the TOS. The best you could hope for is for companies to loudly prevent themselves in their contracts. Of course they could end up going through commercial third parties, or any other plausibly justifiable loophole when they get serious about increasing earnings. Even if they wholeheartedly break your contract and you provably find out, what was your consideration actually worth - a few dollars? You'd be in an even weaker position to show damages than you are now with the NSA.

The ability to consent/decline is indeed a powerful distinction between corporations and government - I believe our world would be much better if every association were voluntary and we could opt out of things we found harmful. But juxtaposing governments/corporations and arguing against one by wholesale endorsing of the other, especially for something as slippery as data, is a Faustian bargain.

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by abritinthebay on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @02:39PM (#10161176)
> It seems like you're perfectly content if Googappazon turns around and voluntarily sells "your" data to governments, since you've consented for them to use it.

Use it under the limited license you agreed to. Not to use it for any purpose at all. This is disingenuous rubbish and you know it.

Re:A Case That Has Microsoft, Apple and Amazon Agreeing by mindslight on Wednesday September 02, 2015 @02:42PM (#10161185)
I had elaborated why the distinction between the two is but a tiny epsilon in the second paragraph. I removed the second part of the sentence you quoted so perhaps people will continue reading rather than having a knee-jerk.

There is no "license" (in the sense of copyright) for the collected data, so there are no builtin penalies for violating the contract. Theoretically a company could commit to $10k in liquidated damages per deliberate privacy violation, but this could be done today so I'll consider it when I actually see such a term in a contract, especially for a free service.

Since you think it appropriate to dismiss me as deliberately writing "disingenuous rubbish", I would kindly ask you to elaborate what you believe my motive is for doing so.

There is certainly a powerful motive to defend private surveillance companies, even if it's just people wanting to believe in what they're creating.