Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth...
by Retra on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:29PM
(#10154169)
You'll want to encode enforcement rules in the laws themselves. Fundamentally, our laws really aren't constraints on what you can do, but guidelines for what you can enforce. You need to take it a step further and write down what you will enforce.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth...
by vezzy-fnord on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:46PM
(#10154323)
But execution and legislation are two separate branches, why are you creating a tightly coupled relationship between them? Writing down explicit paths of enforcement sounds almost guaranteed to be incomplete, and would result in having a high degree of agency being removed from enforcement, because they would now have to follow literal conditions no matter what. Conditions which will almost certainly account for an insufficient number of variables than the ones that will be encountered in reality.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth...
by Retra on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:58PM
(#10154407)
>But execution and legislation are two separate branches,
And cars don't drive themselves. So I guess that solves our problem.
You can read my post below (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10154344) to see how I'd start addressing your other concerns. Basically, if an enforcement officer recognizes some new variables, they can write them down in the law and then enforce it.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth...
by danharaj on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:34PM
(#10154211)
How do you guarantee the enforcement of the rules of enforcement? The fundamental problem is a vicious circle. The abstraction of law leaks.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth...
by Retra on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:40PM
(#10154261)
Every abstraction leaks. That's why they are abstractions and not 'actuals.'
What you do is try it, and when it fails, you manage the failure and modify your system.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth...
by danharaj on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @03:24PM
(#10155022)
Different people have different idea what the actuality of law is. Most people (as Baudrillard would argue) don't ever work with the actuality. Others, mainly the powerful, are quite happy enough to fix failures of the law with copious amounts of force. The abstraction tends to leak bullets. It is very important to emphasize that the law is less than sacred, even an annoyance, to undermine those who will enforce it with the wrong actuality.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth...
by Retra on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @05:31PM
(#10155896)
I fail to see your point.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth...
by danharaj on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @07:02PM
(#10156391)
Attempting to maintain the abstraction of law by fixing it when it leaks has the hazard of bad actors sneaking undesirable elements into our social structures, like violently maintained hierarchy. Adopting a mindset that law is fundamentally flawed and its language is essentially incoherent helps mitigate this possibility.
An example of such incidence is when people trust the police to the point that they prejudge conflicts involving the police on the basis that they represent the law, and the law is good, therefore the police are good. This is still happening.