Or is it a much more limited set of people who, say, send death threats? As a reminder, and quoting from http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/jul/09/tim-hunt-sexi... :
> One female scientist who commented in the media after the story broke told the Guardian she had received “such a torrent of abuse” on social media and blogs that she could no longer face speaking publicly on the matter. Other female scientists who spoke out had apparently also received death threats. “We’ve all been silenced. It’s quite shocking really,” she said. “It’s just not worth the aggro of waking up to calls for me to be sacked on Twitter and hundreds of messages. It was so frustrating to see the perpetrator becoming the victim.”
Two wrongs don't make a right.
The internet is rife with tu quoque. Even, if in the specific case of Hunt and his bigotry, death threats were not made against him it does not mean that this has been the case of all similar internet arguments.
> Does it include people who post "I thing Hunt's comment was sexist"?
No. Just like Hunt is free to be bigoted/racist/sexist, so are people allowed to have opinions about him: so long as those opinions are not designed in such a way to disrupt his personal life or in any way limit his own rights.
> Does it include people who say "I do not think we should invite Hunt for our next 'Women in Science' conference"?
No, so long as Hunt has the right to have his own 'Men in Science' conference without being picketed/harassed or what-have-you.
> > Other female scientists who spoke out had apparently also received death threats.
Much of that paragraph contains content that I would take the man to court over. The objective and irrefutable conclusion is that he actively limited the rights of those female scientists and that behavior is unconstitutional, inhumane and needs to be corrected.
However, "writing a blog post" and the best-case-scenario examples that you cherry-picked are a far cry from what "shame mobs" do on the internet. Indeed, if you believe that mob (of any kind) would resort to such rational and sensible measures then you simply do not know what a mob actually is - it's not a group of people that simply disagree with another group of people.
Without clarification, "shame mob" is a meaningless term because anyone will be able to read into it a wide variety of definitions, including ones that you and I think fall solidly under 'free speech'.
As a historical example, when Republicans supporters shouted "Ma, Ma, where's my Pa?" because presidential candidate Cleveland fathered a child out of wedlock, was that a 'shame mob'? (When Cleveland made it to office despite attempts to use shame to sway public opinion, his supporters responded with "Gone to the White House. Ha, ha, ha.")
If it wasn't, why wasn't it?
I'm not actually sure. The supporters of each opponent certainly seemed to be a bunch of morons acting like juvenile runts; which is indicative of mob psychology. I'm not sure if either went as far as what I would define as a "shame mob" - I simply don't have enough information about the events. Were they harassing by e.g. picketing outside of the opponents' personal residences? Then possibly yes. Merely protesting against [what they believed] an immoral person, in a public place, is perfectly acceptable: especially if that person were a presidential candidate.
If you, like me, don't know what that term means, then did that article make sense to you? Here are the uses of the term 'mob':
"You may be liable to legal sanctions or a twitter shame mob." - in the context of 'like-minded souls [who] via social media ... hold you answerable to their moral standards'.
"The shame mobs that spontaneously form" - that being those people who learned about Hunt's sexist comments at a meeting to support women in science, and attended by international journalists, and who then spread the word. It did not qualify which actions were mob actions.
"The internet allows ordinary people to exercise 18th Century mob justice in a 20th Century way, destroying people's lives bloodlessly from their mobile phones thousands of miles away." - That's an analogy .. and really should be the 21st Century, not? Plus, we've got 20th Century lynch mobs, so there's no real reason to reach back a couple centuries.
"Full scale shame mobs are still rare or course, but that is not all we have to fear.". I think it's appropriate to quote Alice's Restaurant here:
> And three people do it, three, can you imagine, three people walking in, Singing a bar of Alice's Restaurant and walking out. They may think it's an Organization. And can you, can you imagine fifty people a day, I said Fifty people a day walking in singing a bar of Alice's Restaurant and Walking out. And friends they may think it's a movement.
"Third, we could call on the government to save us from the mob [... for example] installing fire-breaks in social media networks that make the formation of flash mobs less likely making it illegal to fire the target of a shame mob without cause and due process" - "flash mob" are also considered good things, like the dance flash mobs that sometimes appear. So "mob" itself isn't the issue, but something more specific.
The author wants there to be legal job protections against the targets of a shame mob. There are already projections for those who complain about discrimination (on the basis of sex, race, religion, and a few other protected categories) in the workplace, so many of the people who protest against sexist comments are already protected.
It's mostly only those who advocate sexism which don't have these protections. So if I read this correctly, it's arguing for more protections for those making sexist and racist comments. And I wonder how the law might define what "shame mob" means in an actionable way.
For that I do have a very clear definition and know exactly what the author is talking about. What I've determined from this debate is that the "Hunt shame mob" is incredibly subjective. Hunt is the type of discussion about this matter which won't come to a conclusion, possibly because his opponents acted in a mature and humane way - it's possibly completely irrelevant to this discussion.
This[1] shame mob is very clear cut: if you are on that list you will have problems being employed in certain industries (read: your rights are now limited). Being placed on to that list is easy: question the common moral compass or fall into demographics that fall within the maintainers' personal bigotry (e.g. religion).
> So if I read this correctly, it's arguing for more protections for those making sexist and racist comments.
Correct. Here's a thing: some years ago (let's say 500) we lived in a world where certain demographics had no rights: up to and including being able to hold a job. This included women, homosexuals and certain races. Freedom of speech was introduced in order to liberate these people: they were given a voice in order to contest the system that was discriminating against them. Specific examples, especially homosexuality, were deemed immoral by the mainstream moral compass. Yet, thanks to freedom of speech, modern people find it hard to believe how people were ever discriminated against like that.
The price of freedom of speech is that you simply can't tie a moral compass to it: because if that had been done, homosexuality would still be immoral today. Who's to say what primitive beliefs our moral compass has? Who's to say what moral battles we'll be fighting in another 500 years time? Will we ever fight those moral battles and enlighten ourselves if we take steps to discriminate against ugly beliefs (such as racism)? Most definitely not. We'd be the same pathetic race who makes pathetic little block lists that affect people's livelihoods; and because of that, the same pathetic race which spreads misery instead of happiness.
To have rights for homosexuals we had to have rights for racists. No human is sufficiently advanced enough to conjure up the perfect moral compass: we prove that day after day. The only solution is, for now, to have no standard moral compass. The mainstream moral compass is not right because it is, itself, still rife with bigotry.
Yes, we have decided that there rights that apply to everyone. I don't know why that's relevant.
We've long established that there are not universal rights in all things. We, for example, prohibit certain types of religious practices, even with the right to one's own religion.
There is of course a tension, but I don't see why this discussion of rights is relevant for this case. In the US case, the issues are the civil rights laws that prohibit discrimination in the workplace, on the basis of race, religion, and several other protected classes. These have long been adjudicated as being constitutionally valid. If someone speaks up in public against sexual discrimination in the workplace, that person's employer cannot (legally) use that as a firing offense, and cannot let that statement influence job related decisions.
We do not extend the same right to other sorts of discrimination, so there isn't a quid pro quo set of rights, which is what it appears that you have suggested.
And we recognize that culture and laws change, so we don't "tie a moral compass" to something and leave it there. Otherwise we would still have slavery.
Those threats were real enough to convict at least two people in criminal court.
There are very many similar examples.
> Two people were jailed on Friday for subjecting feminist campaigner Caroline Criado-Perez to abuse on Twitter.
> Isabella Sorley was jailed for 12 weeks at Westminster magistrates' court. Co-defendant John Nimmo was jailed for eight weeks.
> Judge Howard Riddle said it was "hard to imagine more extreme threats".
> He said that, despite the defendants' claims, the harm threatened against Criado-Perez "must have been intended to be very high".
Is it really a revelation if they openly admit it all along?
Are people not allowed to be who they really are?
You're saying all of this on the very eve of homosexual rights in America, you do realize that?
The only way we got to where we are today is by allowing people to believe "the ugly things" that they believe, to be "the ugly things" that they are - so long as they never hurt anyone.
> revealing
Yet you still use that word. These people often outright declare that they have a primitive moral ground, there is nothing to reveal. Unlike the pretenders on the internet that you praise who, in absolutely no different way, are utterly and convincingly prejudiced to everyone but themselves. With an attitude like theirs, if the first homosexual was born today, they'd never have a chance are fair and equal rights.
> Especially on the eve of a new age of human rights.
This is nothing new. It has been a long and slow journey made by people who can accept that not everyone believes or values the same things; that not everyone's beliefs are the same color of grey as theirs.
Is it so hard to discern the difference between agreeing with someone and accepting someone?
> rather, when you can't work for them because you're a woman, or black, or Jewish. How can this not be obvious?
It's obvious because they aren't allowed to do that. Limiting someone's rights (which they would be doing) is not within their rights.
You do realize that you are saying that a certain demographic shouldn't be hired because they wouldn't hire another certain demographic?
> old white guy
Oh dear... I've realized what I'm arguing against and we're quite done.
Or any number of tricks that are used daily by bigots to fix the game.
Any you realize wrong - you have no idea who I am, and likely your own biases have kicked in. It's comforting to dismiss someone because they're "one of those people", isn't it?
I never said it doesn't happen, I said doing such things makes ones subject to reprimand by law. People are allowed to believe whatever they want to believe, not do to others whatever they want to. How long are you going to ignore my repetition of that point? You might as well accuse me of saying that murder is OK simply because some people get away with it. Laughable.
> you have no idea who I am, and likely your own biases have kicked in.
How can I be biased against you if I don't know who you are?
Either way, there is a difference between avoiding a person because of bias and avoiding a person because the conversation bores you[1]. I've read the same arguments regurgitated without pause for thought 1000 times - the hallmark of which is the "old white man" meme. I'm tired of seeing that same old shit that has very little argumentative value to it.
Cheerio.
It doesn't matter if you say things like that once or a million times. "Quantity" forms no part of the wording that defines free speech or limited speech.
> what is the appropriate way to respond that cannot be described as a "shame mob"?
Technically or practically? Technically nothing should be done (up until the point of fighting words): that person should be left to spout their vitriol as much as they please. People will dismiss him as a crazy racist (a natural consequence) but that does not mean he should be punished/disciplined for being what he is (an additional synthetic consequence).
Practically a friendly hand goes a lot further in changing people's opinions. The only thing these "shame mobs" are doing is inciting more anger: their behavior is as bad, often worse, than the people that they are criticizing.