Anyway, if OpenBSD copies anyone, I'd say copy the Nizza Security or Genode Architectures. They leverage the kind of good components (eg Nitpicker/NOVA) and tactics (eg resource management) I mentioned to QubesOS. I see Qubes since adopted a similar tactic in their graphics system. Has a few novelties but mostly a rehash of virtualization and CMW stuff good against common malware. Need stronger TCB and methods to stop nation-states. Other work at least goes in that direction although not there yet either.
Nizza Security Architecture https://os.inf.tu-dresden.de/papers_ps/nizza.pdf
Genode http://genode.org/
EROS (example of one of best approaches) http://www.eros-os.org/papers/IEEE-Software-Jan-2002.pdf
QubesOS provides a familiar environment where applications can be labeled with different security contexts and run completely isolated from each other. Basically they win on execution right now. I'm sure there are loads of interesting approaches and papers describing how to make things better. But QubesOS is a product and it works. It also provides a user documentation, while genode docs give you c function signatures.
That said, it's usable enough that even I recommend it as an option when strong attackers aren't the opponents. If the attackers are, then it's unlikely to save you and work should be put into the inherently stronger options to get them in better shape. Plus, there's some commercial separation kernels that already run on desktops/laptops etc. one can use. They all use security-focused kernels, user-mode drivers, user-mode networking stacks w/ hardening, trusted boot, I/O MMU, and so on. Not cheap, though, plus a risk of subversion or someone cutting corners. Decisions, decisions. ;)
Truth be told, the whole market (proprietary + FOSS) sucks one way or another. Enemies are probably going to get in if it's a desktop due need to be compatible with much risky garbage. Only the console approaches can be made strong enough with FOSS components right now. Tough trade-offs in ease-of-use, too.
My current recommendation for defending against strong attackers is my old approach: several cheap, hardened machines for physical separation with KVM switch; a guard for sharing between them; sharing done over non-DMA, simple interfaces with simple, easy-to-parse protocols. Additionally, no wireless functionality (even disabled) in them at all. Worked before and still works for less than $1,000 but it ain't pretty or easy to setup.
"Genode provides a "framework" - and basically runs complete systems in separate windows."
Actually, it's a [barely-]usable system differentiated by a resource-management scheme, pluggable microkernels, minimal-TCB native apps, and/or running "complete systems in separate windows." Splitting between microkernel apps and VM's is a proven method that resisted NSA hackers in prior evaluations (eg XTS-400, INTEGRITY-178B). Part that really needs review for risks is their resource-management scheme. However, if proven, it will be advantageous in benefits it offers and especially if microkernel/microhypervisor is enhanced with INTEGRITY RTOS-style resource controls. Malicious apps mostly wouldn't be able to do shit unless there were hardware flaws or problems in the few, trusted components.
Meanwhile, QubesOS runs. So do my Linux LiveCD's and KVM boxes. Malware doesn't hit any of them because the best aren't trying: most targets use Windows or predictable Linux builds. We'll keep using such obfuscation until the [FOSS] strong stuff is ready.
Could you share more about the physical transport for sharing, the data guard (is that a separate box with a Live CD) and wire protocols?
How do you protect against physical threats to unattended devices/data, e.g. do you have any form of trusted boot to verify the integrity of the BIOS, bootloader and OS?
There are many physical transports to use. My original hack was IDE in a non-DMA mode to get past serial's speed limits. Then I/O offloading onto dedicated, cheap computers to pre-process the data and force it into correct spot. Next step was synthesis of the same onto cheap, I/O-focused FPGA's or microcontrollers before I had to put a pause on those developments.
The guard [1] is the strongest part. It used simple hardware(s), a security-focused microkernel, carefully written drivers, optional middleware for internal flow control, and separate partitions for each logical function. Anything incoming is fully scrutinized before moving on. Certain protections, such as encryption, might be applied automatically. The modular, layered, often FSM-using implementation of each thing allows the highest amounts of analysis and verification w/ many errors provably absent. You can also gradually add advanced security technology as it comes online such as SecureCore, Cambrige's CHERI processor, DIFT, Softbound + CETS, etc.
So, the concept is physical separation into different domains. The computers use what they need to use. The Internet-facing ones typically did use LiveCD's and BIOS's I could protect to a degree (eg oldest boxes had jumpers). If it wasn't LiveCD, it was regularly restored from clean backups. Virtualization, hardening, and mandatory controls used as appropriate but I assume it will be toast. Simpler formats like text, HTML 3.2, BMP, and so on for easy analysis by guard. If complex stuff is allowed, it goes over a data diode so any malware isn't leaking things back.
For a similar approach at network/host level, see Boeing's OASIS Architecture [3] that builds on their high-assurance Embedded Firewall (PCI card), SNS Server (highest rating/field-use ever), and a bunch of custom components/strategies. Post-police-state, I'm basically just swapping out Linux distro's as I can't afford to build my old setups any more. My current R&D is on tools such as crash-safe.org, CHERI (w/ CHERIBSD), and the cryptographic methods that all protect system confidentiality and integrity from hardware up. Been working on verified ASIC development flow to implement them with that being done up to RTL level. Current explorations are High-level Synthesis, Analog Synthesis, and my medium-high-assurance RAD methods for software. Post most of my results on Schneier.com, etc instead of my own blog for impact with some companies copying it without credit that we've seen. I can email you those if I haven't.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guard_%28information_security%...
Anyway, my cross-domain system saved a copy of my end of the conversation. My style is to fairly quote other person before each reply so context is obvious to readers. Anything else was ranting filler that was unimportant. You'll be able to clearly see what she was saying. Here's a Pastebin of the two logs.
For what it's worth, I've found the Qubes team to be combative and defensive at times. I especially recall not managing to get straight answers about their VPN and Tor networking modules. But then, both were contributions from users, so their apparently dismissive attitude wasn't totally outrageous.
So, I have no intention of ever depending on it for strong security: just maybe regular malware or containing effects of spyware, bloat, etc.
If you start developing on top of TFC, please create a Github fork at some point and submit pull requests to any typos / issues you might find.
Far as Tinfoil Chat, I've recommended it heartily as a project to use and improve. Markus Ottela took what he learned from prior work and our comments at Schneier's blog (esp on data diodes & physical separation) to create a unique, solid design. He's been posting on the blog for feedback for months, we've suggested many risk mitigations (eg polyciphers, continuous transmission), and he's integrated about every one into his system. Most just ignore such things or make excuses: Markus is 1 in a 1,000 in (a) applying what's proven and (b) not letting problems become legacy "features."
So, yeah, I recommend it. Once my personal situation stabilizes, I plan to reimplement it with a tiny TCB on appropriate devices. I'm probably going to do a portable implementation of Send for microcontroller-style systems. Receive will be a Linux box hardened with virtualization or obfuscation security methods. Genode if it's up to it by then. The transport will be a more hardened, cheap box with just that functionality. I'm going to use CHERIBSD, if possible, just to experiment with it. Might replace the raw, serial links with MCU's or FPGA's for higher-speed, one-way I/O. Optical is highly likely (good guess). Eventually, I'm going to put it in an appliance with several, cheap boards so it's all integrated.
On my extensive backlog for now. But, yes, it's one of the best and practically has no TCB. Great design. Can be reused for email, audio, video, and maybe filesharing. Will be my interim framework until my next high-assurance system is ready.
It's gotten backlogged for me too. I started obsessing about potential EM coupling across optoisolators. But to test, I need a Faraday cage and gear. ...
Anyway, I'll check out the discussion on Schneier's blog.
I'd appreciate whatever links you can share. And I would be glad to credit you.
[1] https://www.qubes-os.org/