News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Solar Sunflower by jacquesm on Sunday August 30, 2015 @11:03AM (#10143493)
I take exception to the use of the word 'invention' here because that most likely implies that patents are at stake. Tech such as this has been tried on-and-off by various parties since the 80's, with many variations on geometry, working fluid, actuation and tracking.

Parabolic segments are a pretty expensive way to do this because it requires moving the collector around. Much simpler and easier to have a stationary reflector harness and actuate the individual mirrors instead, then you can keep the collector on the ground where it is much easier to tie it into something that makes use of the collected energy.

Re:The Solar Sunflower by tinco on Sunday August 30, 2015 @03:21PM (#10144224)
The 'invention' part of this setup is not their mirror configuration, which just looks pretty and possibly is easy for them to build and deploy in spaces where space is a problem. You have to admit that it looks good in that sunflower field. Their footprint looks like it's <2m^2, sort of like a billboard, that makes it very attractive to place wherever.

As it says in the article, the actual interesting part is how they generate the energy, apparently with a GaAs that's cooled with some sort of futuristic microfluidic water system. If that works well just the receptor can be a very profitable product, they can let others worry about mirror configurations and deploying in farm lands.

Re:The Solar Sunflower by Zenst on Monday August 31, 2015 @12:36AM (#10145436)
Maybe the application but tech wise not seeing much new, heat exchanger for electrical generation, satalite dish tracking of a signal (albiet light spectrum).

Maybe if the mirrors had prisms which would focus the light frequency for solat to the cells and would focus the thermal at another spot, that would be neat. Then could of had reflective panels that absorbed the heat and processed there and only reflected the light for solar convertion.

Now be nice if solar heating systems and panels were combined, could have a lens like tube that would absorb the heat but reflect the light towards a solar panel.

Though for me why solar panels do not have large lenses infron as a form of even plastic lens would or glass would work out cheaper than some panel tech and with that use less panels and use less expensive elements and be cheaper over say plastic/glass used to focus. Well that is something I do ponder.

Still hope it works out and if it don't then they will learn lots. But it is sort of just of taking the Archimedes death ray approach http://web.mit.edu/2.009/www/experiments/deathray/10_Archime...

So as you say it will be down to the conversion of light and thermal at one point. But for me that whilst useful (more so in space perhaps) is for me at least complicating a problem in which other approaches would seem easier to engineer (ie collect heat in the panels).

Re:The Solar Sunflower by rayiner on Sunday August 30, 2015 @04:48PM (#10144452)
> Tech such as this has been tried on-and-off by various parties since the 80's, with many variations on geometry, working fluid, actuation and tracking.

And if all those folks didn't succeed, isn't that more reason to give Airlight a patent? Before some competitor realizes that Airlight has fixed the thing everyone else couldn't, then shamelessly copies them?

Re:The Solar Sunflower by venomsnake on Monday August 31, 2015 @12:44AM (#10145458)
There is no inventive step. Just some engineering. They should get patent on what exactly? Cooling semiconductors? Concentrating sunlight?
Re:The Solar Sunflower by nitrogen on Sunday August 30, 2015 @08:13PM (#10144865)
Patents should not be linked to commercial success, if that's what you mean by "didn't succeed".
Re:The Solar Sunflower by Retric on Sunday August 30, 2015 @10:57PM (#10145220)
Lot's of people try and make cancer cures, in theory only the people that succeed get useful patents.
Re:The Solar Sunflower by thrownaway2424 on Sunday August 30, 2015 @01:30PM (#10143931)
Agreed. I saw a demonstration of a unit very similar to the one in the article, that had vacuum-focused thin film reflectors and a sodium-cooled sterling engine. That was in 1997.
Re:The Solar Sunflower by jtolds on Sunday August 30, 2015 @11:44PM (#10145323)
This sort of attitude really bums me out. "Tried it!"

With the current rate of technological advance, a ton of stuff that's failed (and even a lot that's succeeded) should be tried again. Frequently some incremental but necessary technological improvement that didn't exist 10 years ago exists now and it might just change the game. Maybe that's happening here?

Perhaps incremental improvement doesn't deserve the word "invention" but it still deserves a look.

Re:The Solar Sunflower by thrownaway2424 on Monday August 31, 2015 @02:17PM (#10148203)
People who are trying things that already failed should mention why it failed previously and why it will not fail this time. At least journalists who write about such things should be held to that standard.
Re:The Solar Sunflower by monochromatic on Sunday August 30, 2015 @04:05PM (#10144333)
> I take exception to the use of the word 'invention' here because that most likely implies that patents are at stake.

Why shouldn't patents be at stake? Maybe they've come up with something new and non-obvious, or maybe they haven't... we can't exactly tell from this article though.

Re:The Solar Sunflower by stcredzero on Sunday August 30, 2015 @12:00PM (#10143639)
Especially if such reflector units could be mass produced and designed such that their mooring+maintenance requirements are absolutely minimal.
Re:The Solar Sunflower by jacquesm on Sunday August 30, 2015 @12:26PM (#10143720)
I built a (crappy) prototype to test this and it worked remarkably well:

http://pics.camarades.com/v/jacques/renewables/concentrator/

Re:The Solar Sunflower by ChuckMcM on Sunday August 30, 2015 @01:16PM (#10143875)
That is pretty cool, it looks remarkably similar to something one of the Google Energy projects was doing. I tried something a bit different which was to make an actual parabola but to build a mirror reflected the Sun into the same point all the time. (basically you take advantage of the fact that the position of the Sun in the sky for all time/seasons can be calculated for a particular latitude, and then build a reflector where it has a surface for each calculated point.) It works ok, and as a bonus you have something you can put in your lawn which is always annoying your neighbor :-)

The real magic in the sunflower though is that its a dual cycle system harvesting both thermal and electric energy from the system. A lot of "off grid" solar installs will have both PV and Thermal panels as burning electricity to create hot water is really wasteful.

Re:The Solar Sunflower by jacquesm on Sunday August 30, 2015 @04:19PM (#10144378)
> The real magic in the sunflower though is that its a dual cycle system harvesting both thermal and electric energy from the system.

I did the same with that setup above, the collector was water cooled and the hot water could be used. Taught me a ton about what you can and can not do to a normal (cheap) solar panel from a thermal point of view. That's a lot of suns to concentrate on a single panel and the effect on the life span of the panel was quite pronounced, even with sufficient cooling.

The big trick (at least, so I thought) was that I figured out a gearing that would allow you to drive that whole setup with one motor and a small solar panel.

Re:The Solar Sunflower by partisan on Sunday August 30, 2015 @11:50AM (#10143621)
Agreed. The simpler solutions are cheaper and easier to maintain. There are just too many points of failure on a system such as this.