News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Health Care Reform Passes Senate: 60-39 by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 24, 2009 @02:10PM (#1014215)
The claim that it does not add to the Federal debt is an accounting trick. The CBO is legally obligated to stick to a certain set of accounting rules, but this bill was designed to game those rules.

For example, the CBO measures a 10 year time horizon. The plan is for the cost saving measures to begin immediately, while we will only start paying out subsidies in a few years. So the CBO is scoring this bill by comparing the first 6-7 years of benefits to 10 years worth of revenues.

Another game being played is "mandatory" spending cuts. The CBO is required to assume they will occur. Historically, "mandatory" spending cuts are nearly always repealed at the last minute.

Another fairly major aspect of the bill is that it bans no frills insurance (high deductible, excludes routine care). This is likely to induce people to consume more unnecessary medicine (see the RAND experiment).

Re:Health Care Reform Passes Senate: 60-39 by DenisM on Thursday December 24, 2009 @03:10PM (#1014313)
Another fairly major aspect of the bill is that it bans no frills insurance (high deductible, excludes routine care)

Oh my. I had no idea. That was the only insurance that can be called "insurance" with a straight face, and they took that away.

Is there at least an option to self-insure? Or do I need to give $100 to insurance co, just so that they can pass $50 to the doctor for routine care - something I could very well do myself without paying the middleman.

Re:Health Care Reform Passes Senate: 60-39 by sethg on Thursday December 24, 2009 @03:09PM (#1014312)
Jonathan Chait, The New Republic:¹ “According to the Congressional Budget Office, the Senate bill would reduce the deficit by more than one hundred billion dollars over the next decade. Some critics have asserted that the savings are an illusion produced by phasing in the higher taxes more quickly than the benefits, but this is incorrect. At no point do the costs exceed the savings. Indeed, the savings accelerate more quickly over the long run—CBO calculates² that reform will save on the order of a trillion dollars in its second ten years.”

Chait also notes that the bill contains a number of experiments in cost control which the CBO does not credit with any savings in its budget estimates, because we don’t really know yet how effective those experiments will be.

¹ http://www.tnr.com/article/politics/just-noise?page=0,2 ² [link currently broken] http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/108xx/doc10868/12-19-Reid_Letter_...

Re:Health Care Reform Passes Senate: 60-39 by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 24, 2009 @03:40PM (#1014354)
The CBO numbers assume the mandatory spending cuts will not be repealed (since they are required by law to score the bill as written). Such mandatory spending cuts in previous bills tend to be repealed periodically.

Additionally, the CBO also does not account properly for the fact that when you lower the marginal cost of additional medicine, medical consumption increases. This bill bans high deductible insurance , even though high deductible insurance is the only tried and true method for reigning in medical spending.