Re:Health Care Reform Passes Senate: 60-39
by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 24, 2009 @02:14PM
(#1014229)
Community rating: the healthy (e.g. young) must pay for the higher costs of the not-so healthy (e.g. the elderly).
That's rather anti-progressive, no? Force the young and poor to pay for the old and rich? It's great politics, however, since the young don't vote and the old do.
Re:Health Care Reform Passes Senate: 60-39
by sethg on Thursday December 24, 2009 @02:57PM
(#1014296)
Under the Senate bill, insurers on the individual market are allowed to charge older consumers up to four times as much as the young. (Right now, of course, there’s no limit on how much of a surcharge you get on your insurance for age.)
If your family income is under 400% of the Federal poverty line, then you will get a partial subsidy to buy private insurance, and IIRC more people will qualify for Medicaid. So poor people, young and old, are not being screwed here.
Re:Health Care Reform Passes Senate: 60-39
by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 24, 2009 @03:34PM
(#1014338)
Unless rich old people consume less than 4x as much health care as poor young people, it's still forcing the poor to subsidize the rich.
I don't know what it is in Reid's "manager's amendment" version that just passed, or obviously what will emerge in the end if some version gets passed, but the last time I heard a Senate figure it was $750/year.
That's way too low (see the comment about adverse selection). To make the system that's envisioned work, you need three things in balance: universal coverage, guaranteed issue and community rating.
Universal coverage, everyone must be in the system (a fine AKA tax about equal to what you'd pay, with criminal penalties for non-payment).
Guaranteed issue: no one can be turned down.
Community rating: the healthy (e.g. young) must pay for the higher costs of the not-so healthy (e.g. the elderly). Otherwise the latter won't be able to afford it.