I am amazed that it's the year 2009 and serious, honest, intelligent folks think that some massive one-size-fits-all solution is workable for such a complex system. It's the ultimate in Big Design Up Front. After all, with all the difficulties they had for initial passage, do they really think that they are going to be able to iterate? Do they really think they've thought this through? Has anybody? If anything, to me this is a sign that the current legislation is more about hubris and power grabs than real solutions. At the end it's become more of a "we're going to pass something, no matter what it is, and then spin the hell out of it" than real, viable long-term solutions.
And yes, I think Canada's model is great. Push the problem out to 50 states, require them to fix it, let them iterate, and watch a distributed goal-seeking system evolve the best answer over a period of years. This is such a no-brainer I honestly don't even know why it's debatable. Something is seriously rotten somewhere.
The challenge is that when Republicans saw that Obama was serious about health care reform, they trotted out their 1993-1994 playbook, where they managed to obstruct health care reform, and used the resulting negative publicity from special interests campaigning to take control of Congress in 1994. This time around Obama solved the problem by cutting side deals with every special interest he could, and engaging in some truly epic negotiating. The result is pretty much the weakest bill that could be called "reform", loaded down with complex provisions.
However the Democrats are under a deadline. They need to get the thing passed and enough concrete benefits out there to fight the FUD in time for the midterm elections. That is why they have been working so hard - their political lives depend on getting something workable out.
By my understanding now that both house and senate have passed the bill, the Democrats only need 50%+1 to reconcile differences, so they really have come too far to fail. Something will pass.
If the experience of literally every other industrialized country is a guide, the result, suboptimal as it is, will be an improvement on the status quo. Over time it will become very popular, and barring unforeseen circumstances the Democrats will win politically from it for years to come. (Unfortunately for everyone there are a lot of economic train wrecks barreling down on us. For instance the collapse of many companies purchased by private equity circa 2011 and 2012. The Democrats are likely to get blamed for those disasters, and that is likely to matter more come the next Presidential election than health care.)
Personally I'm still unhappy about how this unfolded. I would have liked to see Obama borrow Canada's legislative model. Not their solution, just how Pierre Trudeau got legislation through. What he did is passed a bill saying, Any province that passes some form of universal health care meeting these standards gets per capita transfer payments of this size. That pushed the problem to the provinces with a large carrot. After provinces saw other provinces successfully pass health care, every last province had it within 5 years.
If Obama had done that, then I think he would have had an easier time with legislation because all of the controversial bits would be pushed to the states. And after a few brave states passed it, others could see what works, what doesn't, and most could just wait to adopt a successful model.