News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Psychologists Welcome Analysis Casting Doubt on Studies by TeMPOraL on Saturday August 29, 2015 @09:21AM (#10139880)
When I look at the people I know personally who study psychology, sociology and related fields and see what they learn, I don't have any problems with believing that virtually everybody in the field is incompetent.

It starts with the little things. I remember bringing up on HN the bullshit surveys most students do for their Master's thesis that are statistically worthless for the reasons said students don't understand. I've been told that hey, it's MSc, not a PhD, it doesn't have to be research-quality, etc. But hell, if people are willing to rely on bullshit methodologies for their Master's, when exactly do you think they'll learn the right way of doing things? Does the statistics god dispense additional levels of enlightenment when someone crosses the PhD threshold? I don't think so.

And honestly, it's not that much better in the hard sciences as well, on the undergraduate level. Maybe they won't let you get away with bullshit stats, but they'll happily let you get away with fabricating results and tweaking data to fit the model. Studying today is about only one thing - do everything you can to pass the exam. Research ethics? Never heard of it.

There are no comments on this comment yet.