Re:Two logic puzzles
by dalke on Thursday December 24, 2009 @11:44AM
(#1013982)
What kind of hotel room has moveable safes? The ones in the rooms I've been in are fastened down. What kind of thief would steal anything except for a portable safe? Couldn't you kidnap one of the thieves, steal the clothes, and disguise yourself? How would exchanging safes in the middle of the night not be noticed? Couldn't the henchmen just open up every room looking for them?
Don't safes have built-in locks? My dictionary says a safe is "a strong fireproof cabinet with a complex lock, used for the storage of valuables." That definition does exclude some categories of safe, but "strongbox" or "lockbox" might be a better word.
Having now seen the answer here, I didn't even think that the clasp (shouldn't that be "hasp"?) might be big enough to admit two locks. That seems like a poorly designed safe, since that means the door probably opens enough to admit a crowbar.
Yes, I knew when I started that the answer was "public key cryptography." I'm just complaining that the puzzle wasn't well stated. Besides, if we're going along those lines, what if the henchmen start sending safes into every room to see if it comes back with an extra lock on it? That gives them idea of where the bad guys/spies might be, and prevents the spies from being able to make the exchange.
Don't safes have built-in locks? My dictionary says a safe is "a strong fireproof cabinet with a complex lock, used for the storage of valuables." That definition does exclude some categories of safe, but "strongbox" or "lockbox" might be a better word.
Having now seen the answer here, I didn't even think that the clasp (shouldn't that be "hasp"?) might be big enough to admit two locks. That seems like a poorly designed safe, since that means the door probably opens enough to admit a crowbar.
Yes, I knew when I started that the answer was "public key cryptography." I'm just complaining that the puzzle wasn't well stated. Besides, if we're going along those lines, what if the henchmen start sending safes into every room to see if it comes back with an extra lock on it? That gives them idea of where the bad guys/spies might be, and prevents the spies from being able to make the exchange.