The alternative is inherently unstable, socially: Once people think they have nothing to lose by tearing down the system, it gets torn down. The anti-safety-net capitalists are inadvertently creating a society which will have little to lose from destroying what they're working to build.
They, in turn, insure me against the risk of losing my job, becoming disabled and unable to work and a bunch of other things. They calculate the amount required based on how much I earn, and probably my age/risk profile. No need for a social safety net to protect me from losing my job there.
Sure, a safety net is all nice and dandy. And you could possibly argue that it'll benefit those that can't pay for it like I can, but I'd respond to that in saying that their insurance amount would be a whole lot less. Classic sliding scale. But to be fair, if I was that poor, I'd put more value into having such a fall-back as I'd probably be unskilled labor at that point.
On a side note, when I hear a lot of arguments against an "emergent behavior" system like relatively pure capitalism, I am reminded of the whole "evolution vs intelligent-design" debate. I guess, for me, emergent and self-correcting systems are inherently elegant just by themselves. There is no need for a "creator" (government in this case) to guide the lowly agents to do whats best for themselves within their local constraints.
I know way too many former Programmers who are in dire need of a good government safety net, even in these boom times. This profession has so many variables that scream out for good government safety nets--it's almost laughable: A low barrier to entry?(It's getting easier to learn this stuff monthly.), No unionization. A workplace that's constantly chuning. A really high level of failed companies. Eager workers who will work for free, and I probally forget a lot?
My point is I know way too many former Programmers. Some are even homeless. In fact, in my world, know two homeless individuals personally; they are both former Programmers. One played a big role in Word Star. Everything seems fine in the good times, but when the money gets tight/person gets older--it seems to get ugly. More ugly than pretty much any profession I can think of? All that The Fountainhead thinking kinda works in your twenties-thirties, but the world looks so much crueler after 45--at least for me? There's more than a few things I said/believed in my twenties that I wish I could take back. Basically, I wasen't as slick as I thought?
I do hope that monetization really changed the game, and these companies are becoming more mainstream? But mainstream is not mainstream anymore? I know very few professions that aren't in a remodel, or complete take down? It's about survival, the balance sheet, and a few guys at the top who are literally making a killing. To the guys at the top who aren't spreading it around, read The Price of Privlage, by Madeline Levine. Zero in on the sections about happiness and wealth. It's an eye opener! Even from a someone like myself--who never felt sorry for the wealthy?
The whole time I was listening to this, I was thinking: if a company is going to treat me like a de facto contractor, shouldn't I just ask for the (much higher) hourly risk-adjusted rate I'd demand as a contractor? Why bother with the charade of full-time employment at all?
I get that sometimes you have to fire people because you are running out of money. What I can't agree with is that you can just fire people and it's fine because people's careers are long and this is just another spot in their "journey". Sure, maybe a person will work at many companies over their life.
On the other hand, people work to make a living, sometimes for an entire family, and suddenly not having work can affect someone's livelihood very negatively for obvious reasons. Don't get me wrong, I understand that sometimes as a boss/manager you have to make difficult decisions for the sake of the company. But, you're just lying to yourself if you think it's not a big deal to fire someone.