G places the amulet in his safe, attaches his padlock and locks it with his key, then sends it to K, keeping his key. K receives G's safe, attaches his own padlock in addition to G's (there is a "large clasp", no mention of how large or how many padlocks it could support) and sends it back to G without sending his key. G removes his own padlock, and sends the chest back. K removes his padlock and has the amulet.
Edit: But in real life the first solution might work better. Hard to imagine the henchmen who would be sure to spot you if you left your room even for a moment but would take no notice of servants shuffling back and forth three times with a [double-]padlocked safe.
It is one of the most brain-dead characteristics of school and university exams that one is not allowed to have extras - it's somehow "not fair."
I think not using some of the resources provided is perfectly reasonable.
That's why the solution to the wolf-sheep-cabbage problem is not "just add more floating stuff so you can bring all at once, idiot".
The comparison to school and exams, appears unrelated to me: there are situations where external aid kills the point (e.g. calculator for arithemitic in firs grade).
Recently (for some definition of "recent") I was setting an exam question. In it I gave various lengths, heights, and so on, and I was told that it was too hard because I gave details that weren't required. On the other hand, if one is given only the information required, there is already an artificial clue - all the information given must be used. That's unrealistic.
I've interviewed people for jobs who performed fantastically well on exam style questions, but when given free-form problems simply didn't know where to start.
For me, whether a solution is clean and elegant is independent of whether you've used all the information given. It's the solution itself that's elegant. It's not only plausible but likely that we have different concepts of elegance - I'm a mathematician. When solving math problems, real math problems such as required to get a PhD or publish a paper, there's no way you're given just the information required and no more.
Along those lines I've been moved to submit another puzzle - you can find it here:
If the premise is that it is a 'logic' puzzle and in the end it depends on the cooperation of the servants then in 'real life' there would be no solution.
After all, the 'real life' problem is what sketches the background for this, otherwise why bother with that?
My personal favorite for little (smart) kids:
A farmer has to cross the river, he has with him:
- a wolf
- a sheep
- a cabbage
The boat that hast to take him across the river will only hold one item besides the farmer, what is the sequence of moves that will get the farmer and his possessions to the other side without the sheep eating the cabbage or the wolf eating the sheep ?I agree that the farmer puzzle is nice for kids, but it yields to "try it, oh, that works, ok, I'm done." There's no real insight from it.
Would they take an empty safe? What about a locked padlocked, without a key, not locked onto anything?
I think it's better to make these things explicit in the puzzle.
G places the amulet in his own safe, locks it with the padlock, and keeps the key. G sends the safe to K by way of a servant. K takes the safe with him and uses whatever tools to open it at his convenience once he is safe away.
I think this is wrong, because it's not very satisfying at all. I think it could be right, because (1) it could work in real life and (2) it meets the solution criteria of the puzzle, namely, transferring the amulet from G to K.
I would be happy to know of a more elegant solution.