News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Teaching My Daughter To Code by DaniFong on Sunday January 20, 2008 @07:06PM (#101383)
I'm sending mik the article by Natasha Chen, on how terrible classes organized around syntax killed joy for her, and Scheme revived the magic.

http://www.trollope.org/scheme.html

(here's the comment I left on the blog)

Hi there,

I applaud your efforts, and hope everything is well with you and your daughter.

I do want to raise a note of alarm. I recall struggling through Java and C++ syntax as a kids, and though I did get through without too many scars, I remembered much pain upon reading of Natasha Chen's encounter with programming classes. In this article:

http://www.trollope.org/scheme.html

She details how boring classes organized around syntax displaced creative teaching and work. But she then explained how learning Scheme revived the magic for her: that the extremely simple syntax allowed her to focus on the ideas directly, learning, all the way.

I love Scheme, and it would be a great choice. Squeak, too would be terrific - it seems to have been developed with kid's exploration in mind: (see for example, http://www.squeakland.org/kids/kidsmain.html). Even Java might not be so bad.

But I would take caution. Making GUI apps in Java wasn't very fun. I recall my frustration with Swing and exception hierarchies and paths and packages and altogether it's just not an experience I would revisit. Maybe it's better to learn something designed to be easy. Something designed to grow with you.

There are no comments on this comment yet.