Re:OpenWRT vs. FCC – Forced Firmware Lockdown? [video]
by cpncrunch on Friday August 28, 2015 @06:16PM
(#10138134)
The reason they're doing this is because a lot of crimes have been committed -- resulting in interference with weather radar.
Re:OpenWRT vs. FCC – Forced Firmware Lockdown? [video]
by wyager on Friday August 28, 2015 @08:54PM
(#10138570)
There have also been a lot of crimes committed over the internet. We'd better lock it down.
Re:OpenWRT vs. FCC – Forced Firmware Lockdown? [video]
by task_queue on Saturday August 29, 2015 @03:40AM
(#10139382)
We are and have been.
Re:OpenWRT vs. FCC – Forced Firmware Lockdown? [video]
by madez on Friday August 28, 2015 @07:32PM
(#10138340)
The reasonable answer to that is to regulate wifi frequencies world wide and modify weather radars if necessary. That would solve the interference problem while keeping the firmware open.
Freedom is better.
Re:OpenWRT vs. FCC – Forced Firmware Lockdown? [video]
by cpncrunch on Friday August 28, 2015 @07:43PM
(#10138383)
As I understand it, this was all known when 5Ghz wifi was introduced, so it was a trade-off (see the 2013 NTIA report for details). I don't think it makes sense for them to move all existing services in the 5Ghz band to a completely new band (which might not work anyway, due to the technical requirements of doppler windshear radar). It probably also wouldn't make sense to limit wifi to a small range of the 5Ghz band. However I'm not really an expert on this, so feel free to correct me.
Oh, and you can get freedom -- it's just the radio software that's the issue. The obvious solution is to make the radio software un-flashable, and leave the router software flashable.
Re:OpenWRT vs. FCC – Forced Firmware Lockdown? [video]
by the_ancient on Saturday August 29, 2015 @10:44AM
(#10140118)
However in reality manufacturers will do what ever is cheapest for them under the regulation, not what allows for the most freedom
So under this rule they will simply make the entire appliance non-flashable as it will be the cheapest way to comply with the regulation.
Re:OpenWRT vs. FCC – Forced Firmware Lockdown? [video]
by wyager on Friday August 28, 2015 @08:50PM
(#10138559)
Having government-locked software of any sort is not freedom.
Re:OpenWRT vs. FCC – Forced Firmware Lockdown? [video]
by gpvos on Saturday August 29, 2015 @05:38AM
(#10139514)
Even the FSF is willing to compromise on that, as long as the locked software is hardware-locked and totally unchangeable by anything and anyone (including things like over-the-air updates), so it can be considered part of the hardware, and as long as it does not have access to main memory or can otherwise interfere with the free-software part of the system.
Re:OpenWRT vs. FCC – Forced Firmware Lockdown? [video]
by cpncrunch on Friday August 28, 2015 @09:35PM
(#10138644)
It's only the radio that has to be locked. Why do you need the freedom to reprogram the radio (not talking about the router)?
Re:OpenWRT vs. FCC – Forced Firmware Lockdown? [video]
by wyager on Monday August 31, 2015 @10:04AM
(#10146826)
Why do you need the freedom to reprogram your computer?
The main reason is "because I want to".
The FCC should punish crimes, not impose prior restrictions on innocent people.