News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Your Body Wasn’t Built To Last: A Lesson From Human Morta... by Retra on Friday August 28, 2015 @12:23PM (#10136316)
The distinction you are making is a bit artificial.
Re:Your Body Wasn’t Built To Last: A Lesson From Human Morta... by rfrey on Friday August 28, 2015 @12:26PM (#10136352)
It's not artificial at all. Lifespan is a distribution, what OP describes is moving the distribution around a bit without moving the bounds.
Re:Your Body Wasn’t Built To Last: A Lesson From Human Morta... by kbenson on Friday August 28, 2015 @12:32PM (#10136401)
What if there are no upper bounds, and all there is to work with is the distribution?
Re:Your Body Wasn’t Built To Last: A Lesson From Human Morta... by ska on Friday August 28, 2015 @01:20PM (#10136695)
Do we have any evidence for that view? There is at least some evidence for the converse.
Re:Your Body Wasn’t Built To Last: A Lesson From Human Morta... by kbenson on Friday August 28, 2015 @01:28PM (#10136740)
What evidence is that? What single thing is absolutely sure to kill us by age X?

Specifically, I don't think "aging", which is really a root cause of other things which cause us to die counts. If the problems aging causes could be reversed or cured, then aging no longer would cause death.

Re:Your Body Wasn’t Built To Last: A Lesson From Human Morta... by ska on Friday August 28, 2015 @03:54PM (#10137523)
Telomere shortening would be one example which, if there is no mitigation possible (and we don't have one or know that one is possible) is a pretty hard limit.

That's why I said "some evidence" not "strong evidence", we haven't proven that there is an unavoidable hard limit, but a) we have no evidence that there isn't and b) we know of several mechanisms that look like they may be hard limits.

Re:Your Body Wasn’t Built To Last: A Lesson From Human Morta... by kbenson on Friday August 28, 2015 @04:44PM (#10137750)
I'm aware of telomere shortening, but my understanding is that the theory is not as widely accepted as you imply. I could be wrong though, so feel free to support that,I'm open to new information. That said, it's a limit we may need to overcome at some point if we wish to prolong our lives past a certain point. It's a good candidate for an upper bound on life expectancy, but we still aren't even sure it works as we think. I think that's a good reason why we haven't directly worked on increasing the bounds of life expectancy, we are still definitively identifying them.

Note: I may have come across a bit sharply in my prior comment, but my intent was literally to just ask for the evidence you were referring to and supply criteria I thought needed to apply.

Re:Your Body Wasn’t Built To Last: A Lesson From Human Morta... by ars on Friday August 28, 2015 @12:25PM (#10136339)
Not really. At a certain age people die of "nothing", they just die, without any specific reason.

It's not the same as curing something that kills people early.

Re:Your Body Wasn’t Built To Last: A Lesson From Human Morta... by morcheeba on Friday August 28, 2015 @12:37PM (#10136435)
People don't just die of "nothing" ... it's just that the death is natural and we don't bother investigating. But, usually, it's one of these that kills old people:

http://seniorhealth.about.com/od/deathanddying/tp/cause_deat...

Re:Your Body Wasn’t Built To Last: A Lesson From Human Morta... by smeyer on Friday August 28, 2015 @12:35PM (#10136418)
People don't die of "nothing". When it's said that someone dies of old age, there's still some actual medical cause (although no one is demanding an autopsy to find it when an 85 year old dies peacefully in their sleep).
Re:Your Body Wasn’t Built To Last: A Lesson From Human Morta... by kbenson on Friday August 28, 2015 @12:34PM (#10136415)
I was under the impression that wasn't the case, there's always something, or more accurately, many somethings working together that cause degradation of the system to the point of failure. Are you saying at some point some major organ like the heart just decides to stop beating?
Re:Your Body Wasn’t Built To Last: A Lesson From Human Morta... by JoshTriplett on Friday August 28, 2015 @12:41PM (#10136467)
It's not that there isn't a cause. But at some point, humans start dying of multiple systemic failures, and whatever proximate cause happens to lead to death, the root cause is aging.
Re:Your Body Wasn’t Built To Last: A Lesson From Human Morta... by kbenson on Friday August 28, 2015 @12:50PM (#10136525)
So, similarly to AIDS, the proximate cause is a specific problem, the root cause is AIDS and a reduced immunodeficiency system. The question is, do we treat aging as this unavoidable and untreatable condition that will kill us, or do we treat it as a condition to be managed or cured like anything else?
Re:Your Body Wasn’t Built To Last: A Lesson From Human Morta... by JoshTriplett on Friday August 28, 2015 @12:56PM (#10136561)
> The question is, do we treat aging as this unavoidable and untreatable condition that will kill us, or do we treat it as a condition to be managed or cured like anything else?

Exactly. We need to do the latter, rather than just treating the symptoms. Aging is not untreatable, it's just hard. But it's by far the most worthwhile, because fixing it would fix so many other problems at once.