News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The battle between Washington and Silicon Valley over enc... by georgebarnett on Friday August 28, 2015 @07:10AM (#10134753)
It's seems to me that the inevitable response to back doors will be similar to what has happened following the NSA leaks - secint, sysadmins and devs will update their threat model, excluding the known defective components from the system. In trying to gain deeper access, I believe the government will only lock themselves out further.

Either that or it's a noisy ruse. Make lots of noise about how you're going to backdoor things. Have a great debate and declare it a dead idea, then do it secretly.

Re:The battle between Washington and Silicon Valley over enc... by marktangotango on Friday August 28, 2015 @09:00AM (#10135104)
This is a really good article, balanced and well informed. Is this typical for the csmonitor?

>> Have a great debate and declare it a dead idea, then do it secretly.

Or, putting on my tinfoil hat, they already have means to break arbitrary encryption and they just want back doors (public or in secret) to provide plausible deniability of that fact. An important aspect about having an exceptional capability is not revealing you have that capability.

Re:The battle between Washington and Silicon Valley over enc... by surge on Friday August 28, 2015 @10:25AM (#10135566)
csmonitor puts out surprisingly good well researched articles that compared to other online outlets, aren't rushed to press or are well researched in depth pieces that you simply don't find on many other sites (except maybe Vice or the Atlantic) on occasion.
Re:The battle between Washington and Silicon Valley over enc... by venomsnake on Friday August 28, 2015 @09:30AM (#10135239)
Asymmetrical-would not be surprised. Symmetrical - i doubt. OTB symmetric key exchange will still provide good security.
Re:The battle between Washington and Silicon Valley over enc... by afarrell on Friday August 28, 2015 @11:49AM (#10136105)
> to provide plausible deniability of that fact

Or to provide deterrence to criminal conspiracies without admitting that fact.

Re:The battle between Washington and Silicon Valley over enc... by mhurron on Friday August 28, 2015 @07:51AM (#10134876)
> excluding the known defective components from the system

The problem is, eventually everything legally allowed to be sold in the US would fall under the definition of defective.

Re:The battle between Washington and Silicon Valley over enc... by georgebarnett on Friday August 28, 2015 @07:59AM (#10134900)
That's absolutely an issue and I'm wondering how it will shake out. Whatever happens, if this goes ahead it will be a massive opportunity for non-US players.