Or in other words, cabs aren’t unique.
There are other reasons to regulate. To prevent predatory pricing. Without set prices cab drivers would start ripping people off. You can see the trouble with this with Uber's surge pricing. I needed a cab home from the airport but Uber wanted 4X pricing. Luckly cabs still exist, but in 5 years they might not. My 80 buck fare would be 320 bucks.
A lot of pro uber folks want to pretend that taxi regulations are purely protectionist. But it's really just quid pro quo. You can't tell cab drivers what to charge and make them drive people to anywhere in the city. They might not be profitable. Limiting supply is consultation price.
Well now that deal is done since cities allow Uber to compete with them unregulated.
I think the only real solution is to deregulate cabs. But a lot of people are going to be pissed when their cabbie informs them of surge pricing or that he doesn't deliver to certain areas.
They violate transportation laws flagrantly in most jurisdictions. That's not "unregulated", that's breaking the law.
Is that really true? If so, what makes the cab business so different than every other business where limits aren't put on the number of sellers?
If there were too many cabs and it became unprofitable, then you'd expect the supply to dwindle until it was profitable for some.
The whole safety thing is a different regulatory issue. I could understand trying to keep passengers safe.