Re:Lecture from the Man Who Dropped Both Atomic Bombs
by MrBuddyCasino on Thursday August 27, 2015 @09:19AM
(#10129156)
Very much so. I found there wasn't a single sentence of that old man that I disagree with.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Lecture from the Man Who Dropped Both Atomic Bombs
by cyphax on Thursday August 27, 2015 @09:27AM
(#10129188)
I also found myself agreeing with a lot of what he said, but at the same time, I can't imagine coming to the conclusion that the only way out is to drop not one but two atomic bombs on cities. It's easy to say "but if we hadn't done that we would've ended up killing many more on the ground" but that's speculation, even if it's well-founded. There's no alternative timeline that we can point at and say: look, this is what happened if we hadn't dropped the bombs so we had no choice. There was always a choice and I don't think I could ever make the choice they made.
Re:Lecture from the Man Who Dropped Both Atomic Bombs
by MrBuddyCasino on Thursday August 27, 2015 @10:04AM
(#10129429)
Hmm, I guess thats true. The second bomb probably wasn't necessary. One must not forget though that the conventional firebombing of the vulnerable wood and paper housings had already claimed much more lives up to that point, so it wasn't exactly a difference in the scale of human lives lost.
Maybe the emperor was scared they'd drop one on him? I know the US military discussed that option.
Re:Lecture from the Man Who Dropped Both Atomic Bombs
by sethammons on Thursday August 27, 2015 @08:03PM
(#10132933)
If I recall, America first said, "surrender, or we will unleash an unimaginable weapon upon you." Japan says, "go pound sand." America drops the bomb and says, "if you don't surrender, we will do it again." Japan says, "there is no way you have more than one of those. Pound sand." America drops the next one. Japan surrenders.
Re:Lecture from the Man Who Dropped Both Atomic Bombs
by hga on Thursday August 27, 2015 @08:29PM
(#10133005)
There's also the "Would you prefer to surrender to us, or the Soviets who are currently grinding your Army into sand in Manchuria?" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_invasion_of_Manchuria)?
It would have taken some time for them to have arranged to invade more than Sakhalin Island on down to the Kurils, but it's very possible they might have grabbed some of the home islands, in which case Japan would have a lot more to be upset about than the four of the Kurils off Hokkaido it still wants back: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuril_Islands_dispute