Re:Nuremberg: A Fair Trial? A Dangerous Precedent (1946)
by coldtea on Thursday August 27, 2015 @06:23AM
(#10128542)
>An ad-homenium attack on me? Wow.
No, a lament for the state of historical education in the US. To which I agree with people like Howard Zinn etc.
>Wikipedia is "patriotic BS"?
Wikipedia is whoever writes it. If you consider Wikipedia a scholarly source, then we don't have much to discuss.
Second, It's well known that Japan didn't want an "unconditional surrender". It was a surrender nonetheless, of an exhausted nation, with some provisions mainly to have the emperor save face.
Instead the US burn alive 200.000+ men, women and children, in order to test their new toys and send a message to Japan.
(Note that even if any kind of surrender was off the table, using a nuclear bomb on a war, and on civilian targets nonetheless, is still Nazi-level war criminality).
No, a lament for the state of historical education in the US. To which I agree with people like Howard Zinn etc.
>Wikipedia is "patriotic BS"?
Wikipedia is whoever writes it. If you consider Wikipedia a scholarly source, then we don't have much to discuss.
Second, It's well known that Japan didn't want an "unconditional surrender". It was a surrender nonetheless, of an exhausted nation, with some provisions mainly to have the emperor save face.
Instead the US burn alive 200.000+ men, women and children, in order to test their new toys and send a message to Japan.
(Note that even if any kind of surrender was off the table, using a nuclear bomb on a war, and on civilian targets nonetheless, is still Nazi-level war criminality).