News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:India turned off mobile internet for 63M citizens amid pr... by pjc50 on Thursday August 27, 2015 @05:05AM (#10128327)
It's amazing how many people on this thread are keen to go for the easy, rights-restricting solution (just turn off the internet locally for a bit!) rather than the harder question: why are people primed to riot? Like Ferguson, it's usually a combination of longstanding grievance and trigger event.
Re:India turned off mobile internet for 63M citizens amid pr... by Manishearth on Thursday August 27, 2015 @05:55AM (#10128455)
> it's usually a combination of longstanding grievance and trigger event

That's because riots and such protests are rare in the US; and Ferguson brought new issues to light, not the same old issues.

That's not the case in India. The concept of a "bandh" (close the city and shops, if your shop doesn't comply, you might get beaten up by party thugs) is a common one used by political parties for various reasons. If someone told me that there was a bandh in Mumbai tomorrow, I'd not be surprised, not even really annoyed. One gets used to this stuff.

Riots are a few steps above this, but aren't too uncommon either. Many of them have legit motivations. India is a country of many, many communities and many, many views and it's common for some community to feel aggrieved by something; often rightly so.

This one, I don't think it has a legit motivation either, but I'm not so sure. The reservation system is a rather broken one -- not that I'm saying it should be removed (affirmative action can be quite effective) -- but that it could be improved quite a bit, checking against income and with more safety nets for students/etc who are boosted by this but don't do well. This case seems to be one of people from a non-suppressed community clamoring for reservation, motivated by other non-suppressed communities who got reservation due to a political move (ICBW here).

Thing is, fixing the overall reservation system is a really, really hard problem in practice. There's a lot of politics involved -- anything perceived to weaken it will severely affect your image, and besides, most of these laws need a majority of folks from the relevant minority group to approve them, and due to the way folks vote here, politicians from a minority group depend on that minority group for votes, and if they were portrayed as weakening the reservation system, their political career would be doomed. So the reservation system is something that can only monotonically get worse. Most folks have resigned themselves to this fact.

On the other hand, in Ferguson, the issue is something which the minority group was very aware of, but not the majority group. Many people are now realizing that African Americans look at the police very differently due to the way the police treats them. There's a lot of new information in the system, and there are many proposed solutions, most of which do not qualify as political suicide. It's not the case here, everyone already knows about the issues here, and most if not all solutions are political suicide.

Re:India turned off mobile internet for 63M citizens amid pr... by Manishearth on Thursday August 27, 2015 @10:11AM (#10129476)
[Note: here when I say "new" issues, I mean issues that a LOT of people weren't aware of. Not trying to say that the issues haven't been around for a while, because of course they have :)]
Re:India turned off mobile internet for 63M citizens amid pr... by cma on Thursday August 27, 2015 @08:31AM (#10128983)
> checking against income

Schools do that, and it heavily favors whites. (alumni/donor preference)

Maybe not exactly what you were suggesting

Re:India turned off mobile internet for 63M citizens amid pr... by Manishearth on Thursday August 27, 2015 @08:52AM (#10129057)
I meant the other way around. If you are using affirmative action to benefit minorities[1], try not to benefit folks who are already well off (for a reasonably high definition of "well off"). This issue would be a lot less contentious then. I don't know the stats on this, but anecdotally speaking (this also seems to be a commonly held belief), the majority of the folks who benefit from these things are much, much better off than many of the folks who don't benefit. (Note that the total reservation of seats is around 50% in most places, often more).

Of course, it's not as easy as simply filtering by income by setting a threshhold. In some cases you may want a income-agnostic reservation, too, to prevent caste-based discrimination (not so common in cities, but it still exists), in cases where there are strong human elements in the selection process (i.e. it's not just based on the results of a test, but where there are people in the pipeline who may discriminate). This is something that may need to be handled in a nuanced way.

(Not that I'm saying that reservation is the only solution, just saying that if we want to stay within the confines of this system, it can be improved a lot)

[1] FWIW, in India, everyone is technically a minority, though of course not all minorities have been downtrodden. In this specific case a possibly-non-downtrodden (as far as public opinion goes, this group is in general quite well off) minority is requesting special treatment, which is receiving opposition.

Re:India turned off mobile internet for 63M citizens amid pr... by kang on Thursday August 27, 2015 @05:29AM (#10128404)
Because Indians have accepted that justice won't be served. If you assume that mob justice is what there is, it's the right thing to do. Very sad to say this.
Re:India turned off mobile internet for 63M citizens amid pr... by prateek_mir on Thursday August 27, 2015 @05:18AM (#10128368)
One should note that in cases of communal violence and riots, indoctrination plays a bigger role than grievances.