News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cloud / VPS Apache Performance Comparison by rbranson on Wednesday December 23, 2009 @03:49PM (#1012814)
EC2 scales across instances, it does not burst CPU resources in a single instance. You can't depend on the "burstable CPU" to be available when you need it. It's a highly unreliable form of compute time. You just have to pray and hope no one else is using the same resources on the same physical machine, or you're SOL.
Re:Cloud / VPS Apache Performance Comparison by justinsb on Wednesday December 23, 2009 @04:22PM (#1012889)
Right, I agree that scaling out is great. However, bursting is also a great feature; most loads are bursty (you're caching data and have a cache miss or timeout, you request an admin page which does a lot of computation.) All time-sharing involves statistical reasoning, even within your own application: all requests might be served from cache, or ten people might issue different cache-miss requests near-simultaneously. You just reason that under normal circumstances e.g. 80% of your requests will be served from cache, and that determines your typical load. Short-term bursting means that maybe you can size your machine closer to the mean load, rather than the 2 or 3 sigma load.

So, I want _both_ bursting and scale-out :-)

The benchmark is fair for measuring CPU bursting performance, but we do need a more comprehensive benchmark suite.

Re:Cloud / VPS Apache Performance Comparison by moe on Wednesday December 23, 2009 @11:22PM (#1013385)
Short-term bursting means that maybe you can size your machine closer to the mean load, rather than the 2 or 3 sigma load.

No, it doesn't mean that. Because you can't rely on the resources to be available when you need them. The potential headroom may catch your first two spikes - and then crumble on the third.

Would you buy a second-hand airbag for your car that only "usually works" but is a bit cheaper? Thought so.