Re:Nuremberg: A Fair Trial? A Dangerous Precedent (1946)
by fenomas on Thursday August 27, 2015 @01:15AM
(#10127665)
I recall someone (Hitchens?) pointing out that it was considered a valid defense at Nuremberg if the accused could produce evidence that the Allies had engaged in the same behavior he had.
The comment was meant as an indictment - that the proceedings were mere victor's justice - but in light of this article, it seems to argue strongly for the author's point about legal vs. political proceedings. If guilt is held to be a foregone conclusion and all that remains is to confirm the details and hand out punishments, the argument that it would be better to skip the pretense and trappings of a legal proceeding seems persuasive indeed.
The response I have against it is it suffers from the fallacy of gray. War is horrible and it sucks. Sucks for the old lady cooked to death in a air raid shelter in Dresden, sucks for the GI machine gunned down on the beach at Normandy. Sucks for the Merchantman drowning in the Atlantic. Sucks for the little girl accidentally run over by a jeep North of France.
What ties these together is, none of these people are under the protection of the hostile forces. (And the little girl is an accident)
The difference between what the US army did, or the Soviet Army soldiers did. Was the German Army and police killed people who were supposed to be under their protection. And they did so via policy. That's the difference and that's the body law Nuremberg trials created, that creating such policies was illegal and punishable.
Personally as to the article, that a very fine reasoning about legislative law. But the Nuremberg trials are really about common law. Common law is older, fuzzier, and currently out of fashion, but here we are. The fundamental thing about common law it's it's based not on legislation but in previous rulings. The act comes first, then judgment is passed based on previous rulings and cultural mores.
Fundamentally I think the based on the then current rules of war, the people who were tried under Nuremberg, their lives were already forfeit. The victors had the right to dispose of them anyway they saw fit. Frankly in my view is that the idea that what those people did somehow fell under ordinary criminality is facetious.