X, here, being the Republican base which is, it seems, so much more radical than it has ever been before in my life. Y has all sorts of faults of their own, but there shouldn't be compulsion to hold it up as defense of X.
And this isn't just happening to politics, this is the same human behavior that killed Greenpeace (all of it's founders were pushed aside by radicals) and why you can't tackle any serious issues whether it's wall street or global conflicts. Just try having a movement for a 2 state solutions in the Israeli-Palestinian conflicts you'll start with few ideals that want to open a good dialog, you'll end up absorbing BDS loons, people with signs that praise Hamas, your gatherings end up having "From the river to the sea Palestine will be free" chants that leave not room well for a 2 state solution. Animal rights? pfft you'll end having naked people running and spraying fake blood, social equality? that will turn into a Guy Fawkes look a like contest, the ease of inclusiveness which comes with the modern times pretty much exclude you from dealing with any major issue in a serious manner.