Politicians who are too stupid to realize that raising taxes causes capital flight deserve to lose businesses from their city/state.
Your idea is against the whole notion of private property. "Work like sheep for the government all you business owners and if you move or close it down we're going to arrest you"
>> The union boss, Joe Del Grosso,
non-sequitur. Del Grosso isn't a teacher or a nurse. Unions in New Jersey is a pretty specific kind of entrepreneural activity and well covered in many famous literature and TV works.
>The superintendent, Cami Anderson, demanded accountability from schools but set her own performance goals only after the academic year was largely over and relied on expensive consultants — whose total bill ultimately exceeded $20 million
having grown in USSR/Russia, my first instinctive calculation produces $15M kickback such situation must involve ... of course here things are completely different and expensive consultants is just an expensive and necessary cost of teaching math and reading to schoolchildren :)
Tesla got attacked a lot for their attempts to leverage the best deal possible when pursuing a location for the gigafactory. Articles are still being written about it. I must have read two dozen negative articles against the company regarding that one thing alone. A few of which were on HN's front page. And in that case it wasn't even Tesla threatening to pull existing business from a location.
Why is it seen as an important thing? Ask California how much they've enjoyed Texas pulling business from the state. Of course it's an important consideration, the states compete with each other in most things including where businesses choose to locate facilities.
We could have the same argument with pretty much everything - not only companies / unions.
In the end each party is motivated to use its own power to optimize for their end.
Systems like markets only seek equilibrium if there is a balance in power between parties.
Balance needs to be a neutral position that's still beneficial (read fair) for all sides.
"If you do not do X, I will do Y" is very much the ransom formula regardless.
Saying if conditions change then you'll take a different action is just stating fact. Every change will have it's consequences, that doesn't make it ransom or somehow wrong.
Reactionary changes are just that. Raise taxes or min. wage and businesses move to do what's best for them. That's not ransom.
A) Keyword is "threatening" as in proactive, not reactive.
B) This is the clearly in the context of private individuals demanding stuff from government.
It's just stating the reaction that will happen to proposed changes. And what's wrong with proactively warning the other side? It's the smart thing to do.
The actually important point is that both sides are completely free to do as they like. The company isn't forcefully demanding money or causing harm so there's no ransom or extortion going on here.
You can bust teachers unions.
Remind me again how they are forcefully demanding money?
Perhaps you should read these links:
From the OP of this conversation:
> Why isn't this "ransom" language used when businesspeople threaten to move their business elsewhere, fire people, etc.?
Meanwhile, if a teacher or a nurse says the same thing, you get:
> The union boss, Joe Del Grosso, demanded a ransom of $31 million to compensate for what he felt members should have received in previous years — before agreeing to discuss any labor reforms.
Why isn't this "ransom" language used when businesspeople threaten to move their business elsewhere, fire people, etc.?