News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by kbenson on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:19PM (#10124989)
I don't think so, I think it's just a matter of us learning where our prior ideas of privacy and what should and can be expected are meeting with the new reality. We can not legislate away capabilities that are fundamentally the same as what's existed previously, but have a greater effect because of the digital age, and expect those to hold[1].

Additionally, I increasingly think our interpretation of privacy has been too colored by the recent past (recent in this case being the last couple hundred years). Public privacy is largely a byproduct of increasing urbanization and the anonymity that large crowds provided. In rural areas where someone was around to witness your actions, anyone and everyone might know of it in short order.

I think we will eventually settle on new norms of privacy, where some laws are strengthened, and some are weakened, people are aware of what steps they need to take to be reasonably private in the different areas of their life, and we'll settle into a more normal level of government privacy breaches (they have always existed) than the occurrences we are seeing now (which I believe it a result of our laws and expectations no longer adequately mapping to reality).

1: For example, if a government can legally place a person at a location to observe, I believe any actions to prevent their capability to automate this process (CCTV) will likely fail in outcome, if not legislation.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by nkurz on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @05:55PM (#10126273)
1: For example, if a government can legally place a person at a location to observe, I believe any actions to prevent their capability to automate this process (CCTV) will likely fail in outcome, if not legislation.

Some recent US court cases have reached the opposite conclusion, and decided that a right to privacy from video surveillance exists:https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/12/federal-court-agrees-e...

Although perhaps your standard holds, and the argument would that constant warrantless surveillance would be illegal even if done by a human.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by kbenson on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @10:32PM (#10127212)
Where I think this might cause problems, be likely to be appealed, or are ripe for legislation to change are cases like this where it would have been completely legal to have an undercover agent stake out the house and obtain the same footage of firearms use and thus obtain the same warrant. I don't know if that was the case here (but it sounds like it was). To be clear, I don't think it's impossible to create laws outlawing that situation, or find that current laws find it illegal, just that those cases will be where there is extreme friction between the law and those it applies to, and there will be a higher likelihood to ignore it.

> Although perhaps your standard holds, and the argument would that constant warrantless surveillance would be illegal even if done by a human.

That's possible. Then again, depending on what is outlawed it may run afoul of what I think is a related (and probably root) phenomenon, where something easily accomplished with little risk or cost by the average person is outlawed, and is often ignored. e.g. Jaywalking.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by jsprogrammer on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:25PM (#10125410)
You won't need CCTV. Many already carry around always-connected surveillance devices. Those devices will only grow in number and their capabilities increase.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by kbenson on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:33PM (#10125457)
Yes, but I was using CCTV to illustrate and conceptually link an already existing privacy debate that's been going on for quite a while.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by throwawayaway on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @05:10PM (#10126049)
> We can not legislate away capabilities that are fundamentally the same as what's existed previously, but have a greater effect because of the digital age, and expect those to hold[1].

If you think about genetic predispositions to certain illnesses, and technologically enabled screening for that after conception as a precursor abortion, then you can see how people will disagree with your statement here.

The same principal applies to digital technology, just because people are able to do certain things, does not mean that the law will ultimately allow it.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by kbenson on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @05:31PM (#10126159)
I meant capabilities allowed for and accomplishable without digital help, which may have been unclear.

> If you think about genetic predispositions to certain illnesses, and technologically enabled screening for that after conception as a precursor abortion, then you can see how people will disagree with your statement here.

If it was easily discernible without the internet whether the person had that genetic marker, legislating away the ability to determine it with the internet is destined to fail. The key here is whether the digital age makes it easier to expand and correlate on something already achievable through using your eyes interacting with someone.

For example, I don't believe we can usefully legislate away a company's ability to use information gleaned from the customer during your interaction with them for their own purposes. That's the equivalent of asking a fast food server to wear a blindfold. It will be worked around, because it's ridiculously limiting for little benefit. I think we CAN usefull legislate what passive information companies are allowed to share with outside entities, or require they track additional information that makes it easy for them to respond to requests for removal (such as timestamps for all information that carry through to linked info, so we can require removal specific past info and correlations derived from it).

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by throwawayaway on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @05:46PM (#10126225)
I think something trivial like store employees prompting customers at the till to buy pornographic media that they looked at for too long on the shelf/online, would be legislated against easily.

"I see you've been looking at this porno. Would you like lube with that?".

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by kbenson on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @07:08PM (#10126541)
Displaying overt ads of a specific type at a specific time, probably. Displaying general ads at a general or specific time, possibly. Using that information to do advanced analysis of customers, or do custom tailored time-sensitive (it's payday!) sales, of select inventory they are likely to be interested in? Curtailing them in that manner may be harder to get companies to swallow and live with, and harder for the public to get worked up over. Loopholes would be found, or rules would be ignored, etc.

It's sort of analogous to the friendly neighborhood general store owner Bob knowing his customer Carl is into fishing, getting an expensive but interesting lure, and noting to Carl right after his payday that he has this interesting item Carl might be interested in... I don't see legislation preventing Amazon from doing the same going anywhere.

Sharing that data with outside companies, or restricting it to specific portions of a company with many businesses might be a good candidate for legislation, and also the ability to request specific purchases and associated data or all purchase data for you prior to X be removed.