News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quantitative Economic Modeling in Python and Julia by graycat on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:51PM (#10124776)
Sorry, guys, there's an unfortunate pattern:

In parts of applied math for business, there are lot of talks and papers of the form "Problem X: A Y Approach".

That seems to suggest that there is something really promising about Y. Instead, more appropriate would be "Solving Problem X". If Y was involved, then fine; if not, still fine; that Y was involved really doesn't mean much.

Then also in computing there are talks and papers of the form "Problem X via Programming Tools A and B". So, for the part "A and B", can substitute Python and Julia, Fortran, C and C++, C# and C, C# and C++, C# and Visual Basic, Common Lisp, anything Turing equivalent, etc.

To me Quantitative Economic Modeling is a big enough subject and quite challenging. That some of the computing was done in Python and Julia instead of C, C++, C#, Fortran, Algol, Folderol, etc. strikes me as nearly irrelevant. That is, I see nothing about Python and Julia that promises especially good results on the main challenges of the very challenging problem of Quantitative Economic Modeling.

Where am I going wrong?

Re:Quantitative Economic Modeling in Python and Julia by k2enemy on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:38PM (#10125122)
> Where am I going wrong?

I don't think the goal of the site is to solve the problem of, or even serve as a textbook for, "Quantitative Economic Modeling."

Each chapter presents a popular model that most academic economists are already familiar with and shows, in a practical way, how to implement the models in Python and Julia. I see it more as a resource for economists to learn to program than an an economic theory text.

Re:Quantitative Economic Modeling in Python and Julia by graycat on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @04:03PM (#10125629)
Good answer. Thanks.
Re:Quantitative Economic Modeling in Python and Julia by DMac87 on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:16PM (#10125360)
"Solving Problem X" is not an exciting headline if the community is aware that Problem X has already been solved. The point is that the community may not be aware that tool/approach Y can solve problem X, and might want to see how it is done, to learn about Y, and consider how Y is better/worse than existing tools/approaches.
Re:Quantitative Economic Modeling in Python and Julia by graycat on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @04:01PM (#10125618)
Good. Thanks.
Re:Quantitative Economic Modeling in Python and Julia by grayclhn on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @05:45PM (#10126223)
In addition to the other answers you've gotten (which I agree with and are probably more important than this one) the same advantages that are normally given for working interactively with a REPL apply to scientific computing in economics, probably more than in most fields. (Programming efficiency becomes more important relative to computational efficiency when you're only going to run the program once.) Both Julia and Python are easier to work with interactively than C and Fortran.
Re:Quantitative Economic Modeling in Python and Julia by IndianAstronaut on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @07:43PM (#10126664)
>Both Julia and Python are easier to work with interactively than C and Fortran.

Especially considering the people this is targeted at have a weak programming background.

Re:Quantitative Economic Modeling in Python and Julia by sp527 on Thursday August 27, 2015 @12:08AM (#10127487)
There are entire companies, many worth well into the hundreds of millions, built around dynamic languages. The notion that they can't scale to enterprise-grade application quality is a vestigial exhortation of a bygone era of pedanticism, perpetuated by nerds who saw 'barriers to entry' (obtuse language design) as a way to artificially inflate their own stature. Don't drink the Kool-Aid.