News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by curveship on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:00PM (#10123822)
Holy cow:

    "After my surgery [for cancer], while I was still on
     maternity leave, I received a form letter saying 
     that the health insurance provided by my employer 
     had been terminated. Dozens of panicked emails 
     and phone calls later, the whole thing was, I was
     told, a glitch in the system. After a week of back 
     and forth, I was offered COBRA coverage, by which 
     point I had already switched to my husband’s 
     insurance, where I remained for the duration of my 
     care."
That's a pretty GIGANTIC "glitch," one that turned out hugely in Amazon's favor. Cheiffetz claims she accepts that it was an "administrative error," but you have to wonder. By getting her to switch to her husband's plan, Amazon may have saved themselves hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by xcyu on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:04PM (#10123851)
Sounds like a great application of their Frugality principle. http://www.amazon.jobs/principles
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by josephjrobison on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:31PM (#10124083)
On another note, those are some of the cheesiest stock photos they ever could have picked.
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by magic_beans on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:39PM (#10124685)
I'm sure an algorithm picked them.

Even a design intern working for free could have picked better photos.

Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by rdtsc on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:49PM (#10124270)
I had to look at them preparing for my AWS interview, then I had to parrot the principles back at them through my own experience.

"What was your biggest failure?"

(Alright...let me try to pick one of the leadership principle to parrot back through my biggest failure while also having my self-esteem show down thinking about my failures).

Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by mmagin on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:42PM (#10124715)
Surprisingly they have less of the deliberate yes-we-have-diversity than the usual selection of stock photos used on such a document by a big company.
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by Florin_Andrei on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:03PM (#10124875)
Yeap, they treat their people frugally.
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by ninv on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:08PM (#10123886)
"glitch in the system", sounds like business requirement to me. HR could not reactivate her health insurance so they called it a glitch in the system.

I am sorry for all the folks working there.

Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by MCRed on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:17PM (#10123973)
Yes, one of the big lessons of the corporate world is that almost anything you hear from HR, even in good companies, is a lie. OR at least, some sort of spin. Even when they are saying good things, they don't really know, they're just making stuff up, or exaggerating. It's like they are trained to live in this fantasy world and pitch that to the employees.
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by dudul on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:57PM (#10124332)
Not sure why you got downvoted. This has also been my experience. I've worked at companies ranging from 8 to 300 employees, and everywhere HR has been highly incompetent (most of the time 30 something women spending their time buying shoes online). And when they were competent they were working to protect the company, not employees' ass. HR is never on your side.
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by matthewmacleod on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:32PM (#10124090)
I'm sorry you've had bad experiences, but this isn't really true, in the sense that HR is different from any other department in this regard. Think about it – doesn't the same apply to corporate IT for example?
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by elektromekatron on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:48PM (#10124257)
I dunno, Scott Adams got HR pretty good when he created Catbert.
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by jahewson on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:44PM (#10124726)
Wow, that's ungrammatical.
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by elektromekatron on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:59PM (#10124846)
Or possibly rhetorical writing intended to convey an offhand comment by impersonating the style of speech. Who can say?
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by shazow on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:29PM (#10124598)
I've no insight about Amazon's process with insurance, but being with Covered California we lose our insurance about twice per year due to "glitches" in the system. Each time we find out months later when a claim gets declined and thus requires hours spent on the phone, going through various levels of support.

It wouldn't surprise me at all that the entire health insurance infrastructure in the country is glitchy to the core, but who knows.

Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by ohitsdom on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:08PM (#10123882)
The insurance company saved money, but did Amazon? I thought the portion of premiums that employers pay is fixed? That's why everyone pays premiums- the healthy subsidize the sick. And when there are more healthy than sick, the insurance company profits.

What am I missing, how would Amazon save money by her switching insurance providers?

Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by chimeracoder on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:11PM (#10123912)
> The insurance company saved money, but did Amazon? I thought the portion of premiums that employers pay is fixed?

Large companies actually underwrite their own plans (this is known as self-insuring[0]). The plan is managed by a known insurance company (e.g. Aetna, Blue Cross), so from the employee's perspective it's the same, but the actual risk is borne by the company. I would be very surprised if Amazon did not do this, given their size (~200K employees) and company age (over 20 years).

As a rule of thumb, the break-even point is about 1000 lives covered. Once a company gets to that point, it starts to be in their best interest to underwrite the insurance plans they provide.

Source: Founded a health-tech company that sold to insurers (which meant selling to companies that self-funded their plans as well, as they were they real risk-bearing entity).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-funded_health_care

Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by javajosh on Thursday August 27, 2015 @01:27AM (#10127689)
It's interesting to consider why it's ~1000 and not some other number like 100 or 10,000. It's probably a combination of irreducible information complexity (a system for adding/removing people, processing premiums, investigating claims, paying providers probably costs too much for 100 people) and statistical risk (100 people are chaotic, whereas 1000 people are relatively smooth).
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by sjg007 on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:20PM (#10124003)
Yes but a self insured company should also buy catastrophic reinsurance that covers high claims cases.
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by chimeracoder on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:27PM (#10124046)
Reinsurance doesn't completely let the company off the hook for the costs (in the long run). Even if reinsurance covers 100% of costs above the cap (which it typically does not), those costs will just get factored into the future premiums charged to the company[0] .

It makes it hard to place an exact price tag on how much this employee's coverage would have cost the company without knowing the details, but it's clear that it would have been very expensive to them one way or the other - and certainly a lot more than it cost them to have her switch to her husband's insurance instead.

[0] It's just like how your renter's insurance rates will [often] skyrocket immediately if you try to file any claim at all. People aren't used to this in the consumer health insurance market because there's a lot of indirection in the healthcare system, but that's how all insurance models work at a high level[1], so that's how the costs all (eventually) flow (extra emphasis on "eventually").

[1] There's also the added wrinkle that we also use "health insurance" as a political tool to do things that have nothing to do with risk smoothing at all, so the model gets tricky to unpack, but that's a separate matter.

Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by sib on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:02PM (#10124379)
While I agree with your comment overall, this "It's just like how your renter's insurance rates will skyrocket immediately if you try to file any claim at all" is not true in all cases. I filed what turned out to be a $10K claim for theft against renter's insurance, on a policy that I had only had for about 3 years. The claim was paid in full, with no pushback, even though I did not have receipts for all of the items stolen, and there was absolutely zero increase in premium. The policy has been renewed twice since then, again, without premium increase.
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by ohitsdom on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:29PM (#10125061)
Thanks, good info!
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by ninv on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:12PM (#10123932)
Read this to find answer: http://fortune.com/2014/02/12/why-aol-ended-up-spending-mill...

I thought Tim Armstrong(AOL) is evil but Jeff is on another level. At least AOL did not fire the mother.

Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by superuser2 on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:24PM (#10124553)
This is a ridiculously roundabout way of pointing out self-insurance.

The main reason you are not an insurance company is that insurance only works at scale. But if you have a big enough pile of cash to effectively run your own insurance company, then you can go pay Humana (or whatever) a lot less to just handle the paperwork instead of the actual insurance. It's often a good way to provide better coverage for your employees and spend less money on it, since you aren't paying an insurance company for participation in the risk pool.

But then this does create conflicts of interest where the company is directly incentivized not to pay out for employee health. This isn't particularly worse than the private model; private insurance companies are always incentivized not to pay out.

This is why we need single-payer. You need an actor without a profit motive, and government is it.

Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by chimeracoder on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:09PM (#10124917)
> This is why we need single-payer. You need an actor without a profit motive, and government is it.

That's a really common talking point for single-payer healthcare, but it unfortunately it doesn't hold up under scrutiny. Government-run agencies have the exact same incentives for profit as private companies do, even if they don't use the terms "profit", "margin", and "P/E ratio".

Ironically, the closest thing we have to single-payer healthcare model is Medicare[0], which absolutely does have all the problems associated with a profit motive. In many ways, it's worse, because Medicare is able to set prices across the board by fiat, is not required to negotiate with providers, and is essentially mandatory for providers (so providers just have to swallow whatever reimbursement rates Medicare offers). As a result, providers make an operating loss on Medicare patients[1], to the tune of 7% nationwide.

Think about it from Medicare's perspective. You have to balance your books at the end of the year. Do you either (1) ask Congress to raise taxes to increase your budget and hope they act quickly, or (2) lower the price you decide to pay for services, knowing that it will have zero impact on whether or not providers will still perform services for you? Unsurprisingly, they choose (2).

Also, ironically, most patients who are happy with their Medicare plans[2] are actually using privately managed Medicare plans anyway. So they're essentially opting into profit-driven insurance anyway, with the only difference being that their premiums are being "subsidized" by their past tax withholdings.

[0] There's also the VA, but single-payer advocates usually balk at that comparison since the VA actually operates the medical practice itself, unlike the single-payer models typically proposed.

[1] This means that they make a loss even before accounting for any overhead, such as salaries, or markup.

[2] And at the rate that MA is increasing, pretty soon the majority of all Medicare patients altogether.

Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by mring33621 on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:09PM (#10124920)
Better coverage? What a joke. In the US, self insurance is a way for corporations to avoid state and local laws regarding health care through the use of ERISA. For example, if your state mandates that health insurance plans must cover a minimum set of infertility treatments, ERISA, when invoked through your employer's new self-insured plan, let's call it PlanX, overrides the state mandate and allows PlanX to decline coverage for those same infertility treatments.

Yes, I have experienced this first hand.

Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by chollida1 on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:18PM (#10124516)
The AOL issue is completely separate. AOL self insured which is why they paid out of pocket. Amazon has proper insurance.
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by dec0dedab0de on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:12PM (#10123920)
I thought the portion of premiums that employers pay is fixed?

I don't know about the new laws and such, but that sounds kind of silly to me. Why would they have to pay if she's not covered?

Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by ohitsdom on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:31PM (#10125076)
I meant fixed per person, regardless of medical services rendered. But as others have pointed out, Amazon most likely self-insures, so they take on the risk and stand to gain much by dropping an unhealthy person.
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by TheCoelacanth on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:25PM (#10124562)
Larger companies often self-insure, so Amazon might be paying the actual healthcare bills instead of paying insurance premiums.
Re:“I Had a Baby and Cancer When I Worked at Amazon” by shostack on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @04:39PM (#10125875)
I wonder if there is a legitimate glitch that is at the absolute bottom of a priority list to fix (and stays there) because it makes them more money.

Does insurance have the concept of "breakage" like with rebates in terms of whether people follow through on these "glitches?"