Re:Awesome new (relatively inexpensive) Brain-Computer Inter...
by moron4hire on Wednesday December 23, 2009 @10:20AM
(#1012178)
I don't know, it seems an awful lot like listening to a conference hall for one user's voice commands in an unknown language. Brain-wave activity is largely unknown, not understood, and noisy as hell. There isn't even any concrete evidence that distinct portions of the brain are singularly or wholly responsible for specific tasks. Anything we do related to the brain in this period of human development is not much more than witch doctoring.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Awesome new (relatively inexpensive) Brain-Computer Inter...
by blhack on Wednesday December 23, 2009 @11:05AM
(#1012241)
This is why you would likely have to "train" it.
edit:
here is a relevant link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=40L3SGmcPDQ&feature=relat...
They begin training it at about 13 minutes in.
Re:Awesome new (relatively inexpensive) Brain-Computer Inter...
by tel on Wednesday December 23, 2009 @02:09PM
(#1012606)
Having done work with a similar sort of recording (fMRI, which is actually quite a bit more spatially sensitive to brain activity) I, like the op, don't have a lot of faith in "training" unless someone has developed a fantastic model of the brain's functioning and never talked about it.
That being said, brain-computer interfaces are probably decently possible if they abuse brain plasticity to overload our already highly developed IO systems: our senses and physical actions.
Re:Awesome new (relatively inexpensive) Brain-Computer Inter...
by clistctrl on Wednesday December 23, 2009 @10:45AM
(#1012212)
I'm only theorizing here, but I don't think its trying to look at a specific part of the brain, then determine what you're thinking. It seems to me like there are common actions people can perform that render similar results across everyone (for example it seems like smiling is one) if that is true then you simply need to train the computer what your particular brain looks like after performing this action. Once you have that, you simply map that action to your desired output. The concept is simple (though i'm sure the implementation is wildly complex)
Re:Awesome new (relatively inexpensive) Brain-Computer Inter...
by jcl on Wednesday December 23, 2009 @11:27AM
(#1012289)
it seems like smiling is one
Smiling is perhaps a bad example, since it contracts a muscle near the sensors. When someone is smiling, it's probably hard to detect anything else.