News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Case for Teaching Ignorance by sandworm101 on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @09:02PM (#10120412)
This sort of course isn't for medical school. Maybe undergrad, but to-be doctors have enough on their plate without focusing on the blank areas of scientific knowledge. Once you at a professional school the time for fostering curiosity is long gone. If you;ve dedicated much of your life to a subject then you are already curious.

I hesitate to say such a course could be useful at the highschool level. It would certainly encourage independent leaning and humble many subjects. But it would also become political. It's a fine line between teaching the limits of biological knowledge and preaching intelligent design.

Re:The Case for Teaching Ignorance by kaitai on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:25AM (#10121062)
It is quite important for medical school. Doctors give poor care when they say, "You don't have a problem," rather than, "Science does not know how to deal with this problem." Examples of this include "complementary" medicine that is supported by science (http://www.nytimes.com/2015/08/11/upshot/labels-like-alterna...) but which doctors are not necessarily educated about, and even worse, the false certainty around prostate cancer screening which has led to urination problems and erectile dysfunction and even death for many men who would not have died from prostate cancer (http://www.cancer.gov/types/prostate/research/overtreatment).

Doctors must know the limits of their scientific knowledge or they endanger the lifespan and the quality of life of their patients.

Re:The Case for Teaching Ignorance by shkkmo on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:22PM (#10120663)
There are plenty of medical practices that are used base on historic use and expert opinion (e.g. Trendelenburg position). Doctors should be aware of what the limits of our knowledge are about the efficacy of treatments.

If someone hadn't gotten curious in 2005, we might still be using the Trendelenburg position and potentially harming patients.

I think curiosity should always be encouraged, especially in professional school. I don't think it should be a separate class though, I think we should be teaching the ignorance in every class alongside the knowledge.

There is not a fine line between teaching ignorance and teaching intelligent design. Not at all.

Re:The Case for Teaching Ignorance by dangerlibrary on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @09:04PM (#10120416)
Many MDs go into research.
Re:The Case for Teaching Ignorance by 001sky on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @09:54PM (#10120562)
yeah, not sure that last line fits at all

in the 20th century lots of new material

its importatnt to study the room to grow in every subject

and to constrast the positive space of what is know

with the negative space of what is not

most expertise is simply the ignorance of the unlearned

who hold certain people on pedastals because they don't

know better...think of doctors in the pre-civil war days

would the be considered "experts" today? highly questionable

yet they were the best resources that time/place could muster

every startup is exploring negative space in the market...that's growth potential

a new biz might be intelligent design, but that has nothing to do with evo bio

etc...

doctors are also scientists and biz people and human

And an 18th century doctors is no less a scientist because of his ignorance;

it doesn't make darwin a 'creationist' because he doesn't understand relativity or nuclear physics

obviously absurd example of course