Re:FBI Files on Ray Bradbury (1959)
by adventured on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @02:20PM
(#10118518)
It's not a good idea on paper, that's why it fails in practice and always will. It's a horrifically vile idea on paper, and far more so in practice. The results as you note speak for themselves.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
If you wouldn't mind elaborating more, why is it a vile idea on paper?
AFAIK, every practical implementation of "communism" falls so short of the description, both ideal and transitionally, in things like The Communist Manifesto as to be blatantly lying when they use the name for themselves.
And then you have countries right now like China which blatantly abuse the label. (At the very least: If your country is engaged in capitalism, you are doing it wrong.)
Re:FBI Files on Ray Bradbury (1959)
by happyscrappy on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @04:38PM
(#10119268)
>every practical implementation of "communism" falls so short of the description
And the same for Christianity or any other religion, but at least they had some positive outcomes.
The equivalent to your analogy would be a self-professed Christian worshipping an image of a goat and chanting "hail satan". There's a difference between merely failing as an imperfect human being and actively working against the ideology you supposedly support.
Re:FBI Files on Ray Bradbury (1959)
by happyscrappy on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @06:10PM
(#10119774)
In order to say communism is viable it would be nice to have at least one success to reference. Former citizens of communist countries never cite its virtues, quite the opposite, only confused liberals in the West sing its praises.