News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI Files on Ray Bradbury (1959) by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @02:04PM (#10118400)
> It blows my mind that intelligent people could still be part of the CPUSA in the 50s. It's not like they could play the "well the USSR isn't _real_ communism!" card - for decades the CP had been a blatant Stalin worship cult

It was probably a lot easier and safer for heterodox (from the perspective of the Soviet-affiliated hierarchy) Communists to continue to network with each other within the CPUSA while maintaining a front of orthodoxy within the party outside of their own inner circles than to do so outside, especially given the political climate toward Communists -- without distinctions for variations within that category -- in the broader society.

That being said, nothing in the article indicates that Bradbury was a member of the CPUSA. It indicates that Martin Berkeley, a self-described former member of the CPUSA made a number of claims including:

* "That Bradbury was one of the more prominent writers of science fiction in the United States." (which, apparently, the FBI needed an ex-Communist informant to discover?)

* That Berkeley "felt Bradbury was probably sympathetic with certain pro-Communist elements in the WGAW" [0] (emphasis added)

* That Bradbury denounced supporters of a proposal to expel from the SWG those were Communists or who had asserted their Fifth Amendment rights before the House UnAmerican Affairs Committee as being "cowards and McCarthyites".

* That Berkeley perceived that "some of the writers suspected of having Communist backgrounds have been writing in the field of science fiction" and that "science fiction may be a lucrative field for the introduction of Communist ideologies" (emphasis added, in both quotes)

* That "some of Bradbury's stories were slanted against the United States and its capitalistic form of government".

So, basically, an ex-Communist described Bradbury as someone with (as far as he could describe) no clear Communist links, but who seems like he might remotely be sympathetic to Communist ideology because (1) he writes science fiction, and some other people who write science fiction are suspected (presumably, by the same ex-Communist) of being Communists, and (2) he's opposed to McCarthyism, and (3) some of his writings are read (by, again, the same ex-Communist) as opposing the status quo of the US government.

Its appalling -- but not surprising -- that any of that would be noteworthy and considered as evidence of any dangerous Communist leanings by any thinking person in the 1950s.

Its even more appalling -- and surprising -- that it would be treated as equivalent to membership of the CPUSA by any thinking person in the 2010s.

[0]"Writer's Guild of America, West", formerly "Screen Writer's Guild" (SWG)

Re:FBI Files on Ray Bradbury (1959) by logfromblammo on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @03:22PM (#10118894)
To be fair, the speculative fiction novel is a very convenient platform for illustrating alternate political views. Bradbury, Orwell, Rand, and Heinlein are all technically science fiction writers.

Orwell wrote _Animal Farm_, which is basically one long allegorical denouncement of the Soviet revolution.

Rand is, of course, the founder of objectivism, and explicitly anti-communist.

Heinlein wrote _Stranger in a Strange Land_, _The Moon is a Harsh Mistress_, and _Starship Troopers_. Those describe cultures that are theo-communist, anarcho-capitalist, and stratocratic, respectively. I don't think they are endorsements, as the man himself was largely libertarian for most of his life.

So if Bradbury could be sympathetic to communists, he could also be sympathetic with Klingon High Command, rogue AC repairman Harry Tuttle, Dr. Zaius, and the pirates of Neverland.

The appalling thing is that no one involved in the investigation had the balls to tell their superior that there was no reasonable suspicion there, and it would be a violation of Mr. Bradbury's civil rights to continue with it.