Which is to say it doesn't scale. At all. Rendering it pretty useless at the kind of scale its adherents postulate it at.
Anarchism need not be seen merely as a state of a society. Anarchism can also be seen as a means, a method of collaborating with people. One can see anarchism everywhere in daily life and in struggles that are not specifically for the abolition of states. The root of the many anarchist political ideologies is the thought that a human being is best when she freely associates with her human beings and acts in collaboration with the world. As a method of being, it is useful even to people who care not to get involved in the grand affairs of the world.
Like many ideas and vegetables, the root of anarchism is perhaps its most useful bit.
I think the experiments in Spain actually showed that it would work. Remember, anarchocommunism in Spain was violently crushed by fascists... after the Stalinists betrayed them.
Authoritarianism is authoritarianism wherever you go and its fruits are the same.