Re:FBI Files on Ray Bradbury (1959)
by vidarh on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @01:36PM
(#10118188)
They could rationalise it because they had been 1) lied to by western press and governments for decades and had no reason to trust anything they heard by the time of the Bolshevik coup, 2) lied to by the Stalinist regime by being invited in and presented an nicely dolled up image of the Soviet regime that contradicted what they were told by western press, thus further strengthening the idea they could not trust what they were told.
It's totally unsurprising that a lot of people were taken in - they were on one hand presented with people they trusted telling them they'd seen first hand what the Soviet state was accomplishing, and on the other hand seeing news media they had learned to see as liars confirm that impression by saying the opposite.
It didn't help to have had experiences such as the fawning many right wing elements did over Hitler before the war, or the way Western governments tried their hardest to prevent socialist volunteers from joining the International Brigades against Franco in the Spanish Civil War in the 30's - to many people this meant that the Western governments had no moral authority to speak against Stalin at that point in time; even many people who took issue with Stalin took more issue with Western governments for reasons such as that.
They of course have to be responsible for their own opinions, but why they ended up holding them is not that hard to understand in context.
(Then again, while some moderated themselves as Stalins excesses became accepted even in Soviet circles, as late as '94 I was in a heated exchange where a Norwegian Stalinist told me flat out that if he was in power I'd be in a gulag - some people genuinely believed the methods were justified)
It's totally unsurprising that a lot of people were taken in - they were on one hand presented with people they trusted telling them they'd seen first hand what the Soviet state was accomplishing, and on the other hand seeing news media they had learned to see as liars confirm that impression by saying the opposite.
It didn't help to have had experiences such as the fawning many right wing elements did over Hitler before the war, or the way Western governments tried their hardest to prevent socialist volunteers from joining the International Brigades against Franco in the Spanish Civil War in the 30's - to many people this meant that the Western governments had no moral authority to speak against Stalin at that point in time; even many people who took issue with Stalin took more issue with Western governments for reasons such as that.
They of course have to be responsible for their own opinions, but why they ended up holding them is not that hard to understand in context.
(Then again, while some moderated themselves as Stalins excesses became accepted even in Soviet circles, as late as '94 I was in a heated exchange where a Norwegian Stalinist told me flat out that if he was in power I'd be in a gulag - some people genuinely believed the methods were justified)