News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by acqq on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @06:48AM (#10115535)
"Fundamentalist" as in "religious fundamentalist."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_fundamentalism

Compare their goals to then successful work of Ataturk in 20th century in Turkey:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atat%C3%BCrk's_Reforms

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by afsina on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @07:01AM (#10115573)
Also on the subject, sadly, no matter his visions and good intentions, he was a victim of perfectionism and elitism. No matter what the outcome is, Ataturk was totalitarian at the end and some of his reforms were either unnecessary or executed terribly.

Besides, what is the point? Why are we comparing those two again?

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by gkya on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @08:37AM (#10115978)
You're right in your point that M. Kemal was a victim, but he was not a victim of perfectionism and elitism. He was a victim of some blind nationalism, his admiring of the Occident and his dismissal of the parity of different cultures. He and other people thought that the Europe was better than the other, whereas in fact it was merely different. The revolutions were top down, fascistic, and forced. As you will see, if you read in an objective manner, some history, nearly none the revolutions have changed the things for the better for all. There are still many turks that sustain that Kurdish the language was invented in the 70's, that all the languages descended from turkish, that American indigenous people, Italians, Sumerians and other ancient people of the asia minore were of Turkish descent, that Armenians are the ones that made a genocide at the beginning of the 20th century, etc. People identify themselves basing on lies here. What gives a totalitarian person room to do what he wants? A bunch of hero-gazers that have nothing to base any thought on. See that I do not call people stupid or smart, many ignorant are smart. It's good when one knows that he knows or that he does not know, but the evil is the ignorance of the ignorance, which is our ill as a community of the Near east.
Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by afsina on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @08:57AM (#10116087)
Oh we do agree in the blind nationalism issue, no objections here. I do agree ignorance of ignorance is a terrible thing as well. However, unlike you I try to refrain blanket statements on people of near east, or any other place.
Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by gkya on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @09:29AM (#10116269)
Doesn't the fact that I'm a person of the near east justify me trying to reflect upon my people? I mean, given that I live here, I get to, and have to interact with this people, that I walk among real islamic fundamentalists, real PKK terrorists, real corrupt politicians and their actual supporters? I agree that it's not reasonable to make blanket statements, but I do indeed show the people I make statements about. All I do is to reflect upon the society that I belong to, that I live within and that affects me in the most direct manner.
Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by noskynethere on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @06:55PM (#10119985)
Not if you seek objectivity. You have your own biases, which do not go away because you live/interact there.

It is common for people closest to a subject to have the biggest blind spots.

the wonderful nature of our own biases, perceptive and cognitive, is that it very difficult for us to see them.

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by acqq on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @04:05AM (#10121712)
There is another direction too: farher people should also be vary of not ending with thinking "let them eat cake," from the position of somebody not directly affected by the real problems of those who live them.
Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by afsina on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @09:53AM (#10116446)
I live in Turkey.
Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by acqq on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @07:06AM (#10115587)
You asked "What makes you the "reasonable" and others "ignorant fundamentalists" again?" I'm answering that the division exists and is important and I agree with you that there are better names for the same groups.

But I surely don't want to disqualify the report of a somebody who writes from there only because his report doesn't use what in other environments would be assumed politically correct language.

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by afsina on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @07:12AM (#10115619)
What I am against is that OP, perhaps indirectly, calls Turkish people who votes for/agrees current government as "ignorant fundamentalists" and himself as "reasonable". I think this is degrading and elitist. Maybe I misunderstood him.
Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by acqq on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @07:32AM (#10115707)
It's not name calling if he really believes that those who he names are ignorant. You can discuss with him about what he believes they don't know. Just using the word isn't wrong in itself.
Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by duaneb on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @11:21AM (#10117109)
> No matter what the outcome is, Ataturk was totalitarian at the end

Pointing out you're replacing all his achievements with the fact that he was a totalitarian. This ignores a whole host of subtly.

Nixon started the EPA. Ghengis Khan raped and murdered uncountable ancients, but kicked off a trade network (hell, global economy) and international dialogue that arguably continues today. There's no black and white at all in history.

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by afsina on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @06:54AM (#10115553)
My problem is not on the definitions, but the "name calling".
Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by acqq on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @07:04AM (#10115580)
I agree that calling the leaders of fundamentalists "ignorant" is surely wrong and hugely underestimates their capabilities, as it's known that a lot of planning is involved in their work:

http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/islamic-state-file...

And we also see how effective in working towards their goals they can be.

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by _nedR on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @07:47AM (#10115760)
You missed the key point of the article you linked to:

That IS is not really a group of religious fundamentalists (at least in the higher levels) - rather they are a bunch of Baathists including intelligence people, who are masquerading as religous fundamentalists and exploiting fundamentalists to get back into power.

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by tired_man on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @08:12AM (#10115855)
That has applied to most of the main Islamic terror groups of the last 60 years or so. Do as I say, not as I do. I'm not saying that there were not any leaders who were very devout, just that way too many seem to enjoy a significantly more relaxed lifestyle than their followers.

But that applies to most of the politicians in my country, too, so I'm not throwing stones, just making an observation.

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by acqq on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @07:55AM (#10115787)
Can you please explain where you see I'm missing exactly the point you mention? I understand that you find the point important to you, but I haven't discussed these details specifically.

Leaders are seldom constrained by the ideology they proclaim.

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by _nedR on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @08:30AM (#10115947)
Well, there is a lot of crosstalk here, so there might be bit of confusion. Earlier you were contrasting between religious fundamentalists and 'reasonable' actors :

>"Fundamentalist" as in "religious fundamentalist." >https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_fundamentalism Compare their goals to then successful work of Ataturk in 20th century in Turkey:

>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atat%C3%BCrk's_Reforms

Then you cited IS as an example of religious fundamentalists and linked to an article. My point was that the article you linked to makes the point (at least that was what i inferred) that IS is more 'reasonable'/rational than religious in their calculations and actions (including their cruelty and brutality).

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by acqq on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @04:53PM (#10119373)
Note your statement in the message before

> That IS is not really a group of religious fundamentalists (at least in the higher levels)

I agree if it's about the higher levels, in sense that their goals aren't restricted to the religion but to the power. However even if they aren't secretly just religious they do use the motives of religious fundamentalism to support their actions and to motivate their supporters and followers, and their supporters are rarely aware of the nuances. The leaders do excuse what they do with their religious talks.

> My point was that the article you linked to makes the point (at least that was what i inferred) that IS is more 'reasonable'/rational than religious

I don't agree. We can't equate the higher levels (leaders) and the voters, the supporters and the simple fighters. Only the leaders are those who (by necessity) understand the game (if I remember correctly Bin Laden had the full reports of the US think tanks in his library). The lower levels just religiously believe. Exactly like most of the common people in the US still didn't get that there were actually no WMD and no Al Quaida in Iraq at the time Dubbya Bush (the leader) initiated his war.

On one (higher) level in the same political/religious side, there is rationality, on another (lower) ignorance. User gkya just wasn't able to be precise enough, as you see, it takes time until people who take part in the conversation start to understand one another. And I don't believe I'm elitist when I'm aware of these different levels, just as you've felt that it's important to note the obvious rationality of the leaders (even if you missed to make that difference in the second post).

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by afsina on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @07:09AM (#10115601)
Ok, perhaps there is a misunderstanding here. Why are you referring ISIS here? You were talking about Turkey and Turkish people I thought.
Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by acqq on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @07:15AM (#10115640)
Using the example of extreme fundamentalism we can see that the successful leaders and their close supporters shouldn't be considered "ignorant" even if we are aware how dangerous they are. I also don't claim that they are the only kind of fundamentalists possible.

And if you look at the map, ISIS isn't that far from Turkey.

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by gkya on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @08:43AM (#10116017)
> And if you look at the map, ISIS isn't that far from Turkey.

It's here already.

About your argument on not considering fundamentalists ignorant, they are. First, ignorant does not mean idiot, or stupid. Ignorance is absence of objective knowledge. It's hard to believe that either a fundamentalist would wish to look at things objectively or one that does so would become anyhow a fundamentalist. There may be knowledgeable and smart people exploiting fundamentalists, to them I'm indifferent. All I care is the things that go, monuments, people, peace, the stuff the people are made of. Those are the things that bring tears to my eyes.

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by acqq on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @05:19PM (#10119524)
> Ignorance is absence of objective knowledge.

I agree.

> There may be knowledgeable and smart people exploiting fundamentalists, to them I'm indifferent.

Don't be. They are the real elitists, the ones accepting the suffering of the millions of people as necessary in achieving their goals.

Moreover, their beliefs are also often based on the ignorant premises (religious myths!). A good example of high levels that believe in religious myths are some US politicians:

http://www.dailykos.com/story/2010/01/04/821847/-Republicans...

I'm sure you can identify the equivalent examples by politicians/activists closer to you.

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by gkya on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @06:15PM (#10119804)
I agree to your comment. What I do not like is talking about the secret puppeteers and the mysterious hands between the events. Here in turkey we like this sort of talk a lot. The Jewish rule the world. It's Americans' games anyway. Kurds want independence because there's petrol there. Illuminati. These may be true or not, but I'd rather deal with what I see. Speculations and conspiracies don't get you anywhere. Now I do not know if it's proved that the leaders of the ISIS are the people you say them to be, if such, all my comment is useless, but if not, I'd say that we first cut the tentacles, if we were to attack to the bad monstrous bug, then the head will have no room to escape.
Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by acqq on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @06:55PM (#10119984)
> Speculations and conspiracies don't get you anywhere.

True, but also read once, if you haven't, 1984, the book, per Wikipedia:

"Winston works at the Ministry of Truth, or "Minitrue", as an editor responsible for historical revisionism. He rewrites records and alters photographs to conform to the state's ever-changing version of the truth"

Then try to find how many people know what the countries did before, like:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Cyclone

Always do your own research, sometimes the things that the leaders like to be ignored as the "conspiracy theories" in the current political moment actually happened and give a very different view to the whole context.

Re:Shipwrecks Under Istanbul by afsina on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @08:50AM (#10116051)
All right I am lost already. Where did I praise, defend or reject the existence fundamentalism? And what is the relation ISIS being close to Turkey and OP's emotional name calling on Turkish people?