Re:Ask HN: Why are we still not encrypting email?
by viraptor on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @03:56AM
(#10115071)
I think the webmail (gmail / msn / yahoo) made email encryption so much harder than it was when everyone used their own email clients. You need to install an extension which will talk to your gpg and pray that formatting / line wrapping doesn't break the content. It's even harder with signing only. (encryption will at least result in consistent/short lines) Even in outlook you can simply import your pkcs12 and click sign/encrypt and it's done.
On the other hand, keybase did something nobody else managed before. A number of my friends who never used encryption before actually have their own gpg keys. They may not be using them yet, but the keys are there (and probably in their system keychains) - that's a great first step.
What I think would really push things forwards at this point is an official google extension for chrome/ff/ie which allows gmail to talk to local gpg for signature/encryption. No messing around with textboxes - have it interact with the content as gmail sees it. Of course it would have to be opensource so people can verify it doesn't change the contents... And it should never touch the actual keys.
On the other hand, keybase did something nobody else managed before. A number of my friends who never used encryption before actually have their own gpg keys. They may not be using them yet, but the keys are there (and probably in their system keychains) - that's a great first step.
What I think would really push things forwards at this point is an official google extension for chrome/ff/ie which allows gmail to talk to local gpg for signature/encryption. No messing around with textboxes - have it interact with the content as gmail sees it. Of course it would have to be opensource so people can verify it doesn't change the contents... And it should never touch the actual keys.