News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedia is blacklisted in Russia by osipov on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:42PM (#10114255)
This is typical of the coverage we got with blocking of github and reddit. Very much a knee-jerk reaction with little understanding of the Russian laws and procedures. Of course, it is a mistake to expect otherwise. The problem is that an average reader will come away with an impression: "those backwards Russians are censoring the internet again!"
Re:Wikipedia is blacklisted in Russia by hyperpape on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:54PM (#10114314)
I hope you realize we don't care whose laws they are--we regard that censorship as illegitimate. There's nationalism and chauvinism aplenty, but many of those you'll find criticizing Russia on this point frequently condemn our own governments when they veer into censorship.
Re:Wikipedia is blacklisted in Russia by osipov on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:01PM (#10114346)
>we don't care whose laws they are--we regard that censorship as illegitimate

who's we?

regardless of who you are, your regard of censorship by Russians in Russia is illegitimate. you are a bystander passing judgement, you are not an elected representative of the Russian people. an elected government in Russia made laws establishing the legal process governing this situation. your opinion is interesting but ultimately irrelevant to the problem. those who live and vote in Russia and have a voice on this thread are far more relevant to the discussion than you are.

Re:Wikipedia is blacklisted in Russia by schoen on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:53PM (#10114512)
I guess this suggests that your question about whether people deny countries have the right to censor things probably was rhetorical. Well, I guess you've noticed that a lot of people here don't agree, and think there's a kind of inherent illegitimacy around most information restrictions, maybe regardless of where they come from.

This kind of disagreement seems pretty intractable. :-(

Re:Wikipedia is blacklisted in Russia by narrowrail on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:22PM (#10114431)
Do you realize where this site is hosted, who owns it, and where the majority of its participants come from?

I can only assume the 'we' mentioned is the great many of the HNers who do not like censorship by any country, no matter how nationalistic some of its citizens are.