News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cancer: Diet ‘cures’ are killing young people, say top on... by mikeash on Monday August 24, 2015 @02:20PM (#10111925)
I know a lot of people who believe this stuff, and it's never about the money, except in a vague "big pharma wants to make big profits by killing us" sort of way.

They genuinely believe that mainstream medicine is outright harmful, and that the alternative stuff is better. This remains true even when the mainstream medicine is highly affordable, or even when the person in question has good health insurance.

I saw an interesting case recently. Somebody stepped on a rusty nail (I didn't know that was something that actually happened!) and of course they weren't up to date on their tetanus shot, since vaccines are deadly poison. They asked friends what to do and got a variety of answers, most being some variation on "whatever you do don't get the shot, it will kill you," with various crazy alternative cures proposed. Ultimately they went to an urgent care clinic and got the vaccine. This was described after the fact in a sort of "I know I shouldn't but I didn't have the willpower," the way a normal person might describe how they broke down and ate a tub of ice cream even though they're trying to lose weight. It seems that people still understand on some deeper level that traditional medicine really does work, even if they believe it's "bad" otherwise.

It ultimately looks to me like a variation on religion, where traditional medicine is seen as being sinful and alternatives are seen as righteous. You might come up with rationalizations about why, say, eating ham is bad for you, but ultimately a religious person with a pork prohibition will avoid it because it's just not right. And someone who believes eating pork is sinful can still easily end up wanting it, so it ends up being a weird internal struggle.

On another note, at least among the people I know there is vast overlap between people who use alternative medical treatments and people who believe in stuff like chemtrails. I'm pretty sure there's no financial basis for that one!

Re:Cancer: Diet ‘cures’ are killing young people, say top on... by fredkbloggs on Monday August 24, 2015 @03:09PM (#10112297)
> "big pharma wants to make big profits by killing us"

There's a big difference between distrusting drugmakers and thinking they want to kill you. The last thing they want is to kill you. It's bad PR, to say the least. But more importantly, killing you takes away one of the medical plan's customers. It's the only thing worse than curing you, because they'll never again get money for something prescribed to you. This position is totally unreasonable and no one who considers the situation for even 30 seconds can seriously believe it.

Re:Cancer: Diet ‘cures’ are killing young people, say top on... by mikeash on Monday August 24, 2015 @03:27PM (#10112410)
There are a lot of people who believe totally unreasonable things.

And yes, there are a ton of people who think that, for example, vaccines are deadly, and that they are being pushed by big pharma anyway because of profit motive.

No, it doesn't make any sense. That's not a prerequisite for being believed.

Re:Cancer: Diet ‘cures’ are killing young people, say top on... by fredkbloggs on Monday August 24, 2015 @04:41PM (#10112811)
The vaccine situation is somewhat different, because of the government's involvement in it. If and when there is a government mandate to have chemotherapy, we can talk about them together. Until then, it is reasonable to be more skeptical of vaccines that are required by law than of other treatments. History supports very strongly the idea that you should avoid anything the government tries to force upon you, and that evidence offered by or on behalf of the government is to be ignored.

I'm not an "anti-vaxxer", but I find nothing more abhorrent than the government dictating that something go into your body. It's the darkest of the dark, makes V For Vendetta look like rainbows and unicorns, etc. I would almost certainly believe that vaccines are overwhelmingly beneficial and that the benefits outweigh the risks for nearly everyone, if not for the government's involvement. Once the government is involved, I simply can't trust anything.

Re:Cancer: Diet ‘cures’ are killing young people, say top on... by mikeash on Monday August 24, 2015 @04:59PM (#10112896)
I'm pretty sure the government mandates lots of good things, as well as bad things. I could see saying that a government mandate gives you no information about whether something is good, but outright saying that you should avoid anything mandated by the government as a matter of course just sounds like a way to shut down your brain and avoid having to think for yourself.

Anyway, how is it different? You said above that it's a completely unreasonable position to think that big pharma wants to make big profits by killing us. Lots of anti-vaccine people believe precisely that, and now you're saying you don't find it unreasonable.

Re:Cancer: Diet ‘cures’ are killing young people, say top on... by fredkbloggs on Monday August 24, 2015 @05:37PM (#10113055)
Well, killing people is pretty bad for business, as I explained elsewhere under this article. So I'm pretty skeptical of that motive... normally.

Once you have the government mandating that everyone buy your product, it doesn't really matter any more whether it's a good product or has good PR or is otherwise viewed as beneficial. A drugmaker selling something to the willing has an incentive to make sure it's not lethal, if for no other reason than that the most profitable business is repeat business. A drugmaker selling something the government mandates has no such incentive. This applies, actually, to anything of which purchase is mandated on threat of violence, not just drugs.