Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity
by seiji on Monday August 24, 2015 @02:08PM
(#10111826)
die of hunger while also being grossly overweight
Another fun diets-aren't-thermodynamics argument: rabbit starvation.
Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity
by biomcgary on Monday August 24, 2015 @02:57PM
(#10112224)
Seiji, thanks for the reference.
Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rabbit_starvation) has details. In summary, rabbit starvation occurs on a high protein, no/very low fat diet.
I appreciate your overall point, but would argue that the phrase in not necessarily "trivially true" in some cases. Unlike thermodynamics, biology is not simple. A person could potentially die of hunger while also being grossly overweight if they have a problem with certain metabolic genes. If your catabolic enzymes for lipids do not function, you cannot utilize fat or break it down regardless of your overall energy budget.
That being said, I doubt that very many people have mutations in the genes for those enzymes, since those variants will tend to be selected out of the population.