News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by _delirium on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:12PM (#10110823)
There's a moderate amount of evidence that the type of food plays a significant role in overconsumption of calories. One factor is differing satiation for the same number of calories, i.e. 300 calories of some foods make you feel fuller than 300 calories of other foods. There is also something specifically weird going on with a handful of foods that seem to promote ongoing consumption to degrees seen much less often with other kinds of food. Soda and salty/fat snacks are two where people are observed consuming huge numbers of calories in kind of a chain-consumption binge, which is much less often seen with, say, pork chops or broccoli.
Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by pyre on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:40PM (#10111087)
> There is also something specifically weird going on with a handful of foods

The food industry specifically targets the "bliss point"[1] when figuring out the formula for snack foods.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bliss_point_(food)

Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by balabaster on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:25PM (#10110944)
What about the fact that our chemical laden foods feeds into addiction that perpetuates the cycle? We become addicted to the types of food we consume which causes us to want more than we should. This in combination with increasing portion sizes is exacerbating the problem.
Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by redthrowaway on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:42PM (#10111107)
>chemical laden foods feeds into addiction

Care to explain what you mean by this?

Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by balabaster on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:55PM (#10111214)
There are many articles on the internet - with varying levels of credibility. A quick Google for such things as chemical food addiction should yield many of this type of thing:

http://www.alternet.org/5-unhealthy-foods-engineered-be-addi...

Obviously you will be able to discern which are credible and which are not. That was sarcasm/cynicism, because it's really hard to discern what is credible, to what degree and what the motive of the author was. There is much propaganda on both sides of the fence, so at this point, it's pretty tough, beyond a religious debate to have any objective discussion.

Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by agumonkey on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:39PM (#10111077)
Also quite often documentaries shows (or at least claim-suggest) how much the """"food"""" industry loves to put sugar on top of the remains the sell as meals so it doesn't taste like sand.
Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by balabaster on Monday August 24, 2015 @01:01PM (#10111284)
and corn syrup, monosodium glutamate, BHT, Red dye number whatever it is (Tartrazine) and other chemicals that by all accounts do everything from feed addiction and provoke ADHD and cause cancer, all in the name of profit.
Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by DougMerritt on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:57PM (#10114327)
I'm not sure what you have in mind; Tartrazine is lemon yellow (although of course often mixed to create other colors)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tartrazine

The famously banned "red dye number whatever" I think was red dye number 2, banned in 1976 due to suspected carcinogenicity.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amaranth_(dye)

But there are so many dyes that I can't be sure what you meant.

I will say, though, that although many food additives are ultimately a bad idea in one way or another, historically most of the suspected carcinogens are not, because humans are resilient in ways that mice are not (in part due to two million years of cooked food, and in part due to testing using cancer-prone inbred mice for decades).

Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by balabaster on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @09:15AM (#10116194)
Thanks for the clarification. I was mixing up E102 as it is labelled int the UK (Tartrazine) which was banned in 2013 due to being linked to aggravating/causing ADHD and Red Dye Number 2 which was banned in North America in 1976 due to being a Carcinogen. [One of the downfalls of being an immigrant is that after a while you can never remember (or perhaps just lose the inclination to care) which news applied in which jurisdiction and not the other and which numbering systems belong where]
Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by munificent on Monday August 24, 2015 @01:18PM (#10111427)
I can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not.
Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by balabaster on Monday August 24, 2015 @01:27PM (#10111501)
I wasn't, but I've gotta be honest, it doesn't appear to matter in the context of this specific topic. With the amount of information and disinformation out there regarding food and nationwide obesity levels, it's tough to tell what is and isn't true or to what degree. It's somewhat akin to the propaganda campaigns run by tobacco companies in the 50's, 60's and 70's.
Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by RIMR on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:25PM (#10110945)
>One factor is differing satiation for the same number of calories

>a handful of foods that seem to promote ongoing consumption

>people are observed consuming huge numbers of calories in kind of a chain-consumption binge

As I said: It has absolutely nothing to do with the foods or how they are processed; it has everything to do with how much people eat of these foods.

Fatty/Salty foods can promote overconsumption, but blaming the foods for a person's lack of self-control is, as I said previously, incredibly foolish.

Sure, food trends may have increased the amount of fatty/salty foods on the market in the past 30 years, and this certainly would contribute to the obesity epidemic. However, the burden ultimately rests on the consumer to ensure that they are not only consuming healthy foods, but that they are consuming healthy portions of these foods compared to the amount of exercise they get daily.

I could easily eat 3 Big Macs for lunch, but I am aware that that would be 1600+ calories, so I don't.

Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by balabaster on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:32PM (#10111018)
> As I said: It has absolutely nothing to do with the foods or how they are processed; it has everything to do with how much people eat of these foods. > Fatty/Salty foods can promote overconsumption, but blaming the foods for a person's lack of self-control is, as I said previously, incredibly foolish.

Not everyone has the same self-control/discipline. Exploitation of this fact by food companies is becoming more visible as time goes on. One that immediately springs to mind are the slogans for products such as Pringles: "Once you pop, you can't stop!"

Certain foods cater to, nay exploit, addiction and human behavioral traits. You can't exploit weaknesses in the human psyche and then say "it's their own fault," without assuming any responsibility or blame.

That's like blaming a drug addict entirely for becoming addicted to crack and not apportioning any of the blame to the dealer... not everything is entirely the fault of the... I'm struggling for a better word than victim, but that's not really the word I mean. Most addicts are at first desensitized, then conditioned and then coerced into trying what they become addicted to long before they become addicted.

Food companies have been slated to add chemicals into their food that have been found to correlate with addiction, to keep people coming back for their product. The media desensitizes, conditions and coerces people into trying their product. Portions are decided not based on what is a scientifically proportionate amount of food, but what is most profitable or will make the "client" keep coming back for more - to feed the addiction - in exactly the same way that dealers cut their drugs with chemicals that feed addiction and keep the addict coming back for more - even though many of them want desperately to quit.

Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by yellowapple on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:52PM (#10111189)
> Food companies have been slated to add chemicals into their food that have been found to correlate with addiction, to keep people coming back for their product.

What does this even mean? Barring the more obvious "correlation != causation" issue here, this seems... logically fuzzy at best, and also reeks a bit of the "chemicals are bad" fad. Do you happen to have examples of such chemicals that "have been found [by whom?] to correlate [how strongly?] with addiction [to themselves? to something else? to what?]"?

Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by bglazer on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:34PM (#10111029)
> As I said: It has absolutely nothing to do with the foods or how they are processed; it has everything to do with how much people eat of these foods.

Why and how have people changed to have less self-control in the past 30-40 years?

The most obvious answer is the proliferation of food that is extremely calorically dense and designed to promote fast and heavy consumption.

Or you could wave your hands and say "People these days are just irresponsible!"

Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by RIMR on Monday August 24, 2015 @02:01PM (#10111772)
>The most obvious answer is the proliferation of food that is extremely calorically dense and designed to promote fast and heavy consumption. Or you could wave your hands and say "People these days are just irresponsible!"

Could it not be both? Food may have gotten more unhealthy, but people have also grown more complacent with what and how much they put into their bodies. You can't expect everyone else to coach you on how to eat healthy, you must do it yourself.

Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by bglazer on Monday August 24, 2015 @02:41PM (#10112091)
> Could it not be both?

Sure! It definitely could be. I'd be interested to see if there has been some documented cultural shift, independent of marketing by food giants. One generation seems like a short time frame for that kind of thing though.

But for now, the most direct and clear link is between the food available and people's weight.

Re:A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity by seiji on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:34PM (#10111035)
blaming the foods for a person's lack of self-control is, as I said previously, incredibly foolish.

c.f. http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/24/magazine/the-extraordinary...

burden ultimately rests on the consumer

Rests on the overworked, underpaid, isolated in food deserts, raising kids in the same environment, consumers. The average human isn't researching nutrition science, they just want to be happy. They eat what tastes good, have no time to exercise—they drive 3 hours a day—and then they go back to eating what tastes good.

Humans aren't brain-rational actors, they are gut-rational actors, and the gut is extremely short sighted and happy to offload trillions in future medical expenses onto future members of society (not to mention the national security risk of having 80% of your population rolling around in Jazzy Scooters and individually running up over a million dollars in weight-related medical bills in their lifetime).