News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by cryoshon on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:14AM (#10109848)
Wages are shit for workers and thus consumption/demand are weak... this undermines the Chinese economy, which in turn undermines the US economy.

Labor force participation is also garbage. Savings rates are a bit moot when tons of people are living paycheck to paycheck, also.

It's not 2007-2008, but it's not quite 1998 either.

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by rorykoehler on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:25AM (#10109964)
Capitalism at it's finest. The race to the bottom will eventually force someones (possibly everyones) hand. The mechanism that will drive change (either violent/non-violent) is just a matter of who blinks first.
Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by maratd on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:36AM (#10110062)
> Capitalism at it's finest. The race to the bottom will eventually

What are you going on about? If capitalism is a race to the bottom, we would have reached it a long time ago.

Capitalism isn't new. It's been around for a while.

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by rorykoehler on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:28PM (#10110982)
Produced goods are always getting cheaper. All trends point towards moving towards a zero marginal cost society. Economic pressures and the need to compete are forever pushing prices down. We are also getting more efficient at producing goods in parallel to this trend (another side effect of capitalism). The only way this will stop is through organized price fixing cartels.
Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by TheOtherHobbes on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:06PM (#10110782)
I'm amazed anyone can try to defend a system that has manic-depressive episodes built in as a feature.
Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by merpnderp on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:36PM (#10111047)
Because it's the system that's pulled several billion people out of abject poverty in the last 30 years? I believe the system that was tried before that was called socialism, and didn't work as well as capitalism.
Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by TheOtherHobbes on Monday August 24, 2015 @01:17PM (#10111424)
In Europe socialism created limited working hours, affordable health care, free public education all the way to university level - and beyond - and was also responsible for massive investment in infrastructure and R&D.

Modern social democratic states wouldn't exist without it.

You might want to understand what the word means before running down a political system you seem to know nothing about.

As for abject poverty - there's more of that around than ever. Just because you choose to ignore it doesn't mean it's not there.

And after this week, there's more on the way, too.

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by merpnderp on Monday August 24, 2015 @01:30PM (#10111527)
I'd hardly call Europe socialist. Socialism is the social ownership (state ownership) of the means of production. A welfare state is a state with large programs to ensure the welfare of the people, which better describes much of Europe.

As for extreme poverty, China has seen a 90% reduction in extreme poverty since 1981, and India has seen a 60% reduction since 1981, and Sub-Saharan Africa has seen a 12%. The Indian and Chinese reductions coincided with a relaxation on state owned industry and introduction of free market economic policies.

Hate the corruption, hate the corporatism, but according to the world bank (and nearly every other NGO), capitalism has reduced human misery on this planet like no other force.

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by vezzy-fnord on Monday August 24, 2015 @02:04PM (#10111800)
Socialism is the social ownership (state ownership) of the means of production.

Social ownership != state ownership. That's only one manifestation of it. Socialism has historically been about common ownership, which implies decentralized, democratically structured worker cooperatives. One existing example today is Mondragon.

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by rorykoehler on Monday August 24, 2015 @05:07PM (#10112934)
>(state ownership) of the means of production

That would be Communism, a very extreme form of Socialism. Many countries in Europe are very Socialist.

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by maratd on Monday August 24, 2015 @05:31PM (#10113035)
Communism is state ownership of all property. The parent gave the proper definition of socialism. It is the state ownership of the means of production. Europe is not socialist. There were various attempts, but the means of production is still overwhelmingly private.
Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by rorykoehler on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @05:39AM (#10115354)
Reading Lenin's letters in the Lenin museum in Tampere was very eye opening and educational. Communism was never meant to be the state ownership of all property. It was meant to be the centralized state ownership of the means of production (mainly mining and large infrastructure) with cottage industries (local farmers and makers etc) existing and operating in a free market. Shortly before his death Lenin warned the politburo that Stalin was no good and should be purged from the party. When Stalin came to power he corrupted the original aim of Communism and installed new rules for state ownership to encompass the means of all production and also the proceeds of all production and we all now what happened next.

The commons is a very old concept in Europe. In the UK for example common ownership of agricultural land was the norm until the tragedy of the commons in the early/mid 1800's.

Today Europe is largely a social democracy which aims to walk the line between socialism and capitalism. Again social ownership of the means of production does not necessarily mean state ownership. As vezzy-fnord pointed out Mondragon is a cooperative who came about from the anti-Franco socialist movement in Spain in the mid 1900's. This is most definitely a socialist philosophy operating within a capitalist framework.

Socialism has had a major impact on European politics. The Nordic countries have an immensely strong welfare states due to this, the labour party in the UK (the blip of Tony Blair is an anomaly and they are swinging back to the left now), Sinn Fein (IRA political wing) in Ireland, François Hollande's Socialist party etc etc. Sure Europe operates within a capitalist framework but there is not such a fervent religious belief in unbridled capitalism as one would find in the States. All one needs to do is look at all the anti-trust lawsuits we have in the EU, against the likes of Google and Microsoft, to see how Socialist philosophy manifests itself in contemporary times.

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by maratd on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @09:25AM (#10116241)
> Reading Lenin's letters in the Lenin museum in Tampere was very eye opening and educational.

Since when is Lenin an authority on communism? He was a thug, same as Stalin.

> cottage industries (local farmers and makers etc) existing and operating in a free market.

To his credit, they did do some very interesting things in the 20s. Then Stalin came to power and that ended.

> Again social ownership of the means of production does not necessarily mean state ownership.

Yes, it does.

The USSR was NEVER communist. United Soviet SOCIALIST Republics.

It was a truly socialist state. All the means of production were state controlled, but private property did exist.

The GOAL was to eventually reach communism.

> Today Europe is largely a social democracy which aims to walk the line between socialism and capitalism.

Ok, but the line between socialism and capitalism isn't socialism. As previously mentioned, a welfare state seems a more apt description.

> Socialism has had a major impact on European politics.

Agreed.

> there is not such a fervent religious belief in unbridled capitalism as one would find in the States

There is no "fervent religious belief in unbridled capitalism" in the US. Zero.

Capitalism is a mixture of free market and government subsidy. The government doesn't manufacture anything, but does get heavily involved in the markets through subsidies, regulations, financial instruments, outright purchases of goods, etc. Generally a 70/30 split is considered the norm, where 30% of all market activity is government controlled.

Nobody is excited over this.

There is a "fervent" belief in the free market and the idea that capitalism isn't ideal and that we should tweak that split and reduce government involvement. That we should move toward a free market. That gets people excited.

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by rorykoehler on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:32AM (#10116728)
>There is a "fervent" belief in the free market and the idea that capitalism isn't ideal and that we should tweak that split and reduce government involvement. That we should move toward a free market. That gets people excited.

Serious question. How is this any different than unbridled capitalism? No government involvement and a laissez-faire approach to the market is exactly what unbridled capitalism looks like in my understanding.

Just because Socialism is in the name USSR doesn't necessarily mean anything. If we are to look at the name Nazi which was the National Socialists Party and their Italian counterpart was a major proponent (even father of) of Corporatism, a rather extreme form of capitalism (though in the case of USSR it might be true, as I said earlier Communism is a form of Socialism).

The Welfare State has it's roots in Socialism. Socialism is an umbrella term. Anarchism is a main branch of Socialism (the other two being reformism and Marxism) and to be fair extreme Anarchists don't want a State at all so Socialism cannot and does not mean State ownership. This is one of the major confusions into what Socialism means and kills any possible meaningful discussion around the topic, especially in the USA where Communism and Socialism are used interchangeably. The spectrum of allowable political ideology in the USA is so narrow that only center-right and far-right exist. This is a very unhealthy situation as there are great ideas to be found from across the political spectrum. Just to be clear I'm not saying this to say Europe is better or anything but I do find it an unfortunate state of affairs.

Also Lenin didn't kill 50m+ people just because he was paranoid. You can't lump them together. Stalin was arguably worse than Hitler. While Lenin was certainly not a saint, he was an intellectual with brilliant ideas, operating in an extremely difficult environment.

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by maratd on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @03:30PM (#10118936)
First, read over your post. You capitalize "Socialism" everywhere, but seem to purposefully lowercase capitalism.

If you are so attached to ideology, rather than the results those ideologies bring, we can't have a serious conversation.

> Serious question. How is this any different than unbridled capitalism?

"Unbridled capitalism", no matter how unrestrained, denotes heavy government involvement by virtue of the second word in there.

> No government involvement and a laissez-faire approach to the market is exactly what unbridled capitalism looks like in my understanding.

Your understanding is wrong.

Capitalism requires the accumulation of substantial capital in private hands and its application. And not just any hands, very specific hands, where that capital is magnified.

You can't have that kind of distribution and application of capital without government involvement.

Eminent domain, government contracts, grants, regulations, etc. all direct the flow of capital to the few individuals blessed to wield it.

In short, the government controls and directs the flow of capital. That's capitalism.

> Just because Socialism is in the name USSR doesn't necessarily mean anything.

Yes, it does. It means those who were at the center of the creation of the state saw the enterprise as a socialist one. Even your friend Lenin.

> If we are to look at the name Nazi which was the National Socialists Party and their Italian counterpart was a major proponent (even father of) of Corporatism, a rather extreme form of capitalism

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazism#Economics

"Nazis also promised social policies like a national labour service, state-provided health care, guaranteed pensions, and an agrarian settlement program."

"To tie farmers to their land, selling agricultural land was prohibited."

"Farm ownership was nominally private, but business monopoly rights were granted to marketing boards to control production and prices with a quota system."

Sounds like state controlled means of production to me. I can go on, but you get the point. They were clearly socialist.

> The Welfare State has it's roots in Socialism.

Yes.

> Socialism is an umbrella term.

No. We defined it a few posts above.

> Anarchism is a main branch of Socialism > to be fair extreme Anarchists don't want a State at all so Socialism cannot and does not mean State ownership

You're skipping steps there. Socialism -> Communism -> Anarchism.

Communists aren't fans of government either. They believe(d) that once all private property is out of the picture, there would be no need for government, since there would be no disputes over private property to mediate ... which would lead to a state without government. Leading to anarchism.

> his is one of the major confusions into what Socialism means and kills any possible meaningful discussion around the topic, especially in the USA where Communism and Socialism are used interchangeably.

What? The front-runner for the Democratic nomination openly calls himself a socialist ... that's clearly not true.

> Also Lenin didn't kill 50m+ people just because he was paranoid. You can't lump them together.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vladimir_Lenin#Red_Terror

Ok, so he didn't kill 50m+, maybe 1m?

How do you differentiate between a thug who was responsible for the murder of 50m and one for who was responsible for 1m?

> While Lenin was certainly not a saint, he was an intellectual with brilliant ideas, operating in an extremely difficult environment.

I'm glad to hear he's your hero, but at the end, he's just another murderer. An honest, decent man wouldn't be capable of what he did.

Being intelligent, well spoken, even brilliant ... doesn't excuse you from being a shitty human being.

Stalin was also quite brilliant. That doesn't excuse him either.

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by coldtea on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:41AM (#10110116)
>What are you going on about? If capitalism is a race to the bottom, we would have reached it a long time ago.

Only for a long time it had internal pressure (workers demands) and external pressure (the Cold war etc). Else we'd be still with child labor, 14 hours work day and such...

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by icebraining on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:04PM (#10110775)
Workers and their demands are part of capitalism, as one of the sides of the labor market.
Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by coldtea on Monday August 24, 2015 @05:36PM (#10113051)
Not if capitalists can prevent it, crush it, disallow it, etc -- along with their friends in the goverment, with "right to work" laws, etc.

It's funny that for something supposedly pragmatic and empirical, as capitalism, there are people invoking the "no true capitalism" defense.

I mean when they say that in "true capitalism" the government would not interfere and the market would adjust itself etc, where in real life (and in all know historical cases), the government is in the pockets of powerful moguls and big business lobbys).

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by wutbrodo on Monday August 24, 2015 @06:03PM (#10113165)
> It's funny that for something supposedly pragmatic and empirical, as capitalism, there are people invoking the "no true capitalism" defense.

This is hugely disingenuous. It's about as fair as crying "no true socialism" if someone were to say "moving towards socialism leads to mass famine! Just look at Mao!".

I think part of what makes conversations like this so frustrating for everyone involved is that people are using vastly different definitions. Those decrying capitalism are usually defining "socialism" as a mixed-market economy and capitalism as an unfettered "pure" Randian market economy. (In conversations critical of socialism, you usually see the opposite dynamic).

The fact of the matter is that mixed-market economies are basically ubiquitous at this point, and for good reason. It's a lot easier to find a common understanding on which to debate when everyone is clear what the actual disagreement is: the market is good at certain things and bad at others, and gov't action is a sensible alternative in the areas it's better at (of which there are quite a few, not least dealing with externalities) or a damaging hindrance in the areas where it's worse than the market mechanism (explicitly setting prices, in most cases). The disagreement is over which things go in which category, which is a far less flame-baity way of thinking of it than "capitalism/socialism is just bad!".

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @12:07AM (#10114554)
> the market is good at certain things and bad at others, and gov't action is a sensible alternative in the areas it's better at (of which there are quite a few, not least dealing with externalities) or a damaging hindrance in the areas where it's worse than the market mechanism (explicitly setting prices, in most cases).

I don't think that's actually true[1]:

>Two German microeconomists tested the “widely accepted” hypothesis that “prices in a planned economy are arbitrarily set exchange ratios without any relation to relative scarcities or economic valuations [whereas] capitalist market prices are close to equilibrium levels.” They employed a technique that analyzes the distribution of an economy’s inputs among industries to measure how far the pattern diverges from that which would be expected to prevail under perfectly optimal neoclassical prices. Examining East German and West German data from 1987, they arrived at an “astonishing result”: the divergence was 16.1% in the West and 16.5% in the East, a trivial difference. The gap in the West’s favor, they wrote, was greatest in the manufacturing sectors, where something like competitive conditions may have existed. But in the bulk of the West German economy — which was then being hailed globally as Modell Deutschland — monopolies, taxes, subsidies, and so on actually left its price structure further from the “efficient” optimum than in the moribund Communist system behind the Berlin Wall.

Or in other words, mixed economies can easily operate just as far from the Efficient Market Hypothesis as centrally-planned economies. The Efficient Market Hypothesis should probably be considered more like a Carnot engine than like a real internal combustion engine: some substantial degree of inefficiency is probably an inevitable result of operating in the real world.

[1] -- https://www.jacobinmag.com/2012/12/the-red-and-the-black/

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by icebraining on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @04:09AM (#10115104)
The Efficient Market Hypothesis should probably be considered more like a Carnot engine than like a real internal combustion engine: some substantial degree of inefficiency is probably an inevitable result of operating in the real world.

That's a specious conclusion; the paper explicitly says that the inefficiency is due to the degree of management present in West Germany, which was significant.

It's not like the EMH says the market prices are theoretically perfect; it only says they're better than whatever individual or group can calculate. And the paper you cite provides evidence for that.

"To sum up, the unexpected similarity of overall deviance between actual prices and eigenprices in East and West does not warrant the conclusion that East German pricing behaviour was not so bad after all and more or less guided by relative scarcities. In those sectors where market forces prevail in the West, East German actual prices deviate significantly more from eigenprices. However, the similarity of the overall indicator testifies to the fact that a sizeable part of West German GNP is not produced under competitive market conditions. It obviously is the case in sectors with predominant public ownership rights and strong government influence."

(Emphasis mine)

https://www.europa-uni.de/de/forschung/institut/institut_fit...

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by wutbrodo on Saturday September 05, 2015 @05:07PM (#10176035)
> the bulk of the West German economy — which was then being hailed globally as Modell Deutschland — monopolies, taxes, subsidies, and so on actually left its price structure further from the “efficient” optimum than in the moribund Communist system behind the Berlin Wall.

This isn't really contradicting what I said. As they say, the gap in the West's favor was greatest in the places where the market was relied upon in contrast to a system full of "monopolies, taxes, and subsidies". Neither West Germany nor East Germany had particularly market-oriented economies.

To wit, the market mechanism efficiently provides a price level but that doesn't mean you can't mess it up by poorly planned gov't intervention in the economy (and to be clear, I mean "gov't intervention that is poorly planned", not that gov't intervention is per se ill-advised).

Re:Stocks Off Sharply as Market Upheaval Grows by cma on Monday August 24, 2015 @04:52PM (#10112855)
Things like Taft-Hartley outlaw secondary strikes.