I also wanted to mention that where I've worked and many other places there is a crisis of brain drain at companies as the mainframe experts who are highly paid retire out and there are programs to recruit young people who are more attracted to other platforms. There is a lot of pay and job security in the field. I know of one situation where a guy past retirement is paid full salary to work 1/3 of full-time from his vacation home because the company could not afford to lose his knowledge and struggled to find someone competent enough to learn under him that was interested in mainframe. In other words, someone young with these skills would be highly paid and in higher demand at many companies.
http://www-03.ibm.com/systems/z/education/academic/masterthe... and https://www.facebook.com/MasterTheMainframe
I get the feeling it's mostly legacy plus scenarios where the rigor IBM applies is valuable and you go along with whatever they suggest.
What makes them "faster" in many cases is that the decades old apps were written by people "with a clue" and they run pretty much on the hardware. I've had a joke going for a few years, that websphere was created to cause efforts to port off the mainframe to fail.
AKA its pretty much impossible to take something running in ztpf, rewrite it in java and plunk it on a EC2 instance and have a hopes chance in hell of making it work without spending more than the next two decades of mainframe maintenance costs in monthly amazon bills.
That doesn't mean you can't rewrite it in C++ on a DL580 with an attached Flash840 and leave the mainframe in the dust if you have competent programmers.
The zSeries selling point is not the hardware, but the reliability (which is in fact the hardware). The z in that series stands for zero down time and they are not selling hardware, but close to 100% reliability.
Now in reality, no one can guarantee zero down time, but IBM does in fact guarantee 5 nines (99.999%) and 6 nines (99.9999%) up time and that guarantee costs money.
You certainly can't get those sort of up-time numbers using nothing but commodity hardware.
Another way to view this: since mainframe workloads have existed for a long time, if their performance was way beyond what you can still accomplish with commodity hardware, then we should see tech companies utterly flocking to these systems. We should see IBM selling their chips all over (after all, why wouldn't Microsoft want to get in on the action?). No one wants to deal with huge fleets of servers. If they could just give IBM some money and be done, they'd do that, no?
But instead it's mostly used for older, risk adverse, applications. So while I've no doubt they end up delivering solid systems, I'm skeptical that the scale is more massive than people are used to.
There is a z/OS security talk I saw that partially dispels the myths and prejudices against mainframes as legacy. In some cases z/OS is more modern than what you might find on your desktop and OSs like Linux are implementing features in its kernel that have been in zOS for years.