News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by coldtea on Sunday August 23, 2015 @04:06PM (#10106584)
>think its important for Hacker News readers to read this because techno-communism is becoming a very serious force in western politics. It needs to be tempered with a historical context.

Tempered why? The worst thing he could say about Poland was a corrupt police. Constrast with the hundrends of innocent police killings in the US, or the hundrens of thousands incarcerated for BS charges (like drug pocession or three-strikes) and it's not that different. Widespread surveillance? Check, and even more detailed.

Of course there are differences too. E.g. now nobody is guaranteed to have a job or a home, and inequality can be much higher than in those old times (where a party functionary just made something like a few times more, not several orders of magnitude more, like a CEO does).

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by x0054 on Sunday August 23, 2015 @04:38PM (#10106668)
Come on! Did you live through Soviet style communism? Please don't glorify that BS unless you have. A party functionary would be entitled to free servants to help them move, clean there garden, do all kinds of physical labor for them. Those servants were called enlisted soldiers. A party functionary would be entitled to a yearly, 3 month vacation on the black sea, where they would live, in a palace by the sea. And when I say a palace, I mean literally a fucking palace. There were very privileged people in the Soviet union. Now it's true that even those people would constantly live in fear, because on minute you could be on top, and the next you are dragged off by the secret police.

And guaranteed house? Like the house that my best friend grew up, with his mom, his dead, and his sister, all sleeping in the same bed in their 250 sqft studio.

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by coldtea on Sunday August 23, 2015 @07:35PM (#10107178)
>Did you live through Soviet style communism?

No, but I lived through a military dictatorship sponsored by the US (though, admittedly, 30+ years later Clinton on an official visit did say the US was sorry for its support of it) imposed on my country so that a large percentage of my countrymen who preferred socialism wouldn't attempt to try it.

Oh, and it was preceded by a prolonged civil war (provoked by the UK, and with the right-wing side given arms and support by the UK and US in a typical Cold War scenario), followed by 15+ years of imprisonment, exile and even torture for tens of thousands of the most prominent left sympathizers, among them war heroes who had just before fought heroically against the nazis, like this guy:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manolis_Glezos

So, yeah, there was that side too.

>And guaranteed house? Like the house that my best friend grew up, with his mom, his dead, and his sister, all sleeping in the same bed in their 250 sqft studio.

And in our modern day and age, in advanced countries, there are tons of people living all 4-5 of them on the same trailer house. Or even worse, being homeless. And that's in a place like the US. In Mexico, Latin America, Africa, Asia etc it can be much worse.

So, while bad in itself, I'd say a guaranteed 250 sq ft studio for 4 people, plus a job for all of them, plus the basics, plus education, etc, sure beats people living in the slums in 1/3 of the modern world, e.g. as in:

http://www.theguardian.com/books/2006/aug/19/shopping.societ...

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by x0054 on Sunday August 23, 2015 @08:52PM (#10107360)
So you lived through a military dictatorship sponsored by US and UK, and during that time tens of thousands of your countryman died due to the government. So obviously the Soviet system, which under the rule of Stalin killed millions of people (as in close to 50 million) during that same time is much better. Yes a job for everyone, even if that job is digging up ice dirt in the Siberian Gulag until you die from exhaustion. Come on, have some perspective, both systems are totalitarian regimes with horrible outcomes for the populations. In your case they were killing, torturing, and exterminating the left leaning intelligentsia. In the Soviet Union they did exactly the same thing to all the right leaning intelligentsia, actually all intelligentsia, because smart and educated people might see through all the bull shit the party was shoveling down people's throats. At the end of the day, in both cases a ton of people died horrible deaths simply because of what they believed in. How is one system better then the other? Well, other then in absolute terms, because at least in your case they didn't manage to killing quite so many people, but the outcome is the same. I am amazed that someone who lived through one totalitarian regime would be so in favor of another! Any system that subverts the rights of an individual under some bullshit pretense that it's for the "good of the nation" is absolutely wrong!
Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by coldtea on Monday August 24, 2015 @09:32AM (#10109539)
>So you lived through a military dictatorship sponsored by US and UK, and during that time tens of thousands of your countryman died due to the government. So obviously the Soviet system, which under the rule of Stalin killed millions of people (as in close to 50 million) during that same time is much better.

As an aside, the oft quoted “50 million” number is BS. It counts famines, deaths in the war, etc. That said, the regime did execute a million or so directly. OTOH, it was a period of revolution and turmoil (even if it was skewed by the rise of bureacrats, etc). Death toll should be compared to things like the Civil War, not to peacetime statistics.

That said, I never mentioned USSR, and the “soviet system” (or rather “socialism” is not a single thing, nor where the conditions the same in every place. Poland was different, Czechoslovakia was different, East Germany was different etc.

>Yes a job for everyone, even if that job is digging up ice dirt in the Siberian Gulag until you die from exhaustion.

Are you really familiar with the history of those states, or just repeat what you’ve read or seen in movies about very specific periods and very specific countries? Because that reflects a tiny percentage of the Eastern Europe population, and for a specific period of time. If we’re allowed to cherry pick periods, we can say “yeah, land of the free, unless your job is picking cotton under Jim Crow laws”, etc.

>In the Soviet Union they did exactly the same thing to all the right leaning intelligentsia

Actually they did it more to the left leaning intelligentsia there too. Because the problem with USSR wasn’t that it was “too left” and thus despotic, but that it wasn’t left enough (e.g. the revolution turned right into a self-preserving regime). Those who were in the right (mostly wealthy families etc) had mostly immigrated to the west early on. It was the "more leftists" that got the shaft from Stalin and co (of course usually undersevedly labeled as "right").

>At the end of the day, in both cases a ton of people died horrible deaths simply because of what they believed in. How is one system better then the other?

Well, with that metric no system is good. Capitalistic colonial powers, for example, have enslaved 2/3 of the world, hundreds of countries and billions of people, and have caused more deaths than Hitler and Stalin combined (including the genocide of native americans).

>Any system that subverts the rights of an individual under some bullshit pretense that it’s for the “good of the nation” is absolutely wrong!

Well, and what about individuals in other countries, bombed, killed, having dictatorships imposed upon them by the same government?

Just a case (there are countless others, in Latin America and elsewhere): http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/aug/19/cia-admits-role...

Or are only citizens “individuals” and foreign people don’t matter? Even so there are a million black people in jail in the US, aren’t they individuals or don’t they have rights? Or its that they are disproportionally criminal to the white population (which again has a disproportionate incarceration rate compared to the rest of the world). I won’t even mention the death penalty, which the civilised Europe has left behind.

Maybe we should chalk that system as “absolutely wrong” too?

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by x0054 on Monday August 24, 2015 @03:30PM (#10112431)
> As an aside, the oft quoted “50 million” number is BS. It counts famines, deaths in the war, etc.

The number I quoted is adjusted for the war related deaths. As for the famines engineered and caused by the Soviet Government, please do not minimize those deaths by saying they do not matter. Members of my grandfathers family died during that time because of the famines and because of how the Soviet government was literally stealing the food from Ukraine.

> Poland was different, Czechoslovakia was different, East Germany was different etc.

I did not live in Communist East Germany, Poland, or Czechoslovakia, but I am sure many people on this board have. And I am sure that most of them have stories to tell about how terrible those governments were. You haven't lived though any of those regimes either, so please do not pretend like you know best.

> Are you really familiar with the history of those states, or just repeat what you’ve read or seen in movies about very specific periods and very specific countries?

I was borne in Ukraine in 1984. I lived through the tail end of it, but my Mom and Dad, as well as my grand parents, lived through the thick of it. Not every one was send to Siberia, but many people were. My grandfather was a Ukrainian military doctor, so he was part of the "party," but he was a very conscientious man, and his hart would bleed for the poor conscripted soldiers he was treating. The Soviet government would literally use them as slave labor. When Chernobyl meltdown happen, my grandfather was sent to triage the injured. He was stationed miles away from the reactor, treating the injured soldiers coming back from the power plant. They were dying from radiation poisoning, and the Soviet government would just send new once in there, to die.

You see, in the communist country, a human life is worth nothing. If it's easier to send a 1,000 soldiers to die, they will do that, no questions asked. I know, soldiers are sent to die all the time, but these poor guys didn't have a chance, not a chance. I realize that US did the same in Vietnam, and it's wrong. But 2 wrongs don't make a right.

> Or are only citizens “individuals” and foreign people don’t matter? Even so there are a million black people in jail in the US, aren’t they individuals or don’t they have rights?

Again, you can't argue that because US has it's problems, and is doing a lot of really wrong things, now and in the past, that somehow this makes all the horrible things that the Soviet government did just pitchy. I lived through the tail end of communism, my parents lived through a lot of it. We moved to US as soon as we could. And with all it's problems, I would take US over USSR any day of the week.

I understand that you lived through a dictatorship, that Greece is right now in a complete financial ruin, in large part due to the idiotic way the EU is setup, and that you probably want to blame EU and US for all of it. But don't look to Russia and the olds style USSR for answers, the answers they have are the wrong answers. My fear is that if Greece does not recover from it's problems soon, they will be tempted to do a deal with Russia and Putin. Your opinions are not unique in Greece, I believe. I really hope that doesn't happen.

In any case, you are not going to see it my way, and I am not going to see it your way. So let's part here.

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by selimthegrim on Sunday August 23, 2015 @09:10PM (#10107401)
At first I didn't believe the UK bit but then I read the book by Mazower, "Inside Hitler's Greece". Everybody who thinks their colonial outrages were limited to the Fuzzy Wuzzies and the Mau Mau should read it.
Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by ido on Sunday August 23, 2015 @05:30PM (#10106812)
Hate to nitpick but you mean "dad". "Dead" means not-alive.
Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by V-2 on Sunday August 23, 2015 @04:25PM (#10106636)
> The worst thing he could say about Poland was a corrupt police.

It hardly means that this is the worst thing that could be said about Soviet-controlled Poland

> Constrast with the hundrends of innocent police killings in the US

US police is notorious for its brutality, but are these killings ordered by top officials in chain of command?

If factory workers go on a strike in the US, are police troops sent in to "shoot to kill" them? They did in Poland 30 years ago, eg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacification_of_Wujek

> E.g. now nobody is guaranteed to have a job or a home

A guaranteed home for which you would wait 20 years :))

While earning 20 bucks a month.

For which you often couldn't even buy basic goods...

http://i.wp.pl/a/f/jpeg/22380/kolejka_prl_internauta_550.jpe...

http://i.wp.pl/a/f/jpeg/23333/puste_haki_550.jpeg

^ Equality.

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by coldtea on Sunday August 23, 2015 @07:50PM (#10107236)
>US police is notorious for its brutality, but are these killings ordered by top officials in chain of command?

Directly no. They are just nurtured by top officials in chain of command, who could have stopped this shitty behavior in a day if they wanted to, but instead either ignore it or even encourage it.

From people arming police departments with military grade equipment and allowing SWAT teams etc to be used for BS offenses, to right-wing politicians speaking of blacks, latinos etc as lazy, criminals, gloryfying the use of police force, etc.

>If factory workers go on a strike in the US, are police troops sent in to "shoot to kill" them? They did in Poland 30 years ago, eg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacification_of_Wujek*

Back in the day, yes:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludlow_Massacre

And if unions got that organised again to be a threat, then I have no dount they would. Heck, they even killed students:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kent_State_shootings

Not that I'm a fan of those "eastern bloc" states, but I want to put things in some perspective. Saying "they just earned 20 bucks a month" is not enough -- one also has to know how things were for the majority of people in these countries before socialism, in order to compare.

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by V-2 on Monday August 24, 2015 @02:39AM (#10108224)
> Saying "they just earned 20 bucks a month" is not enough -- one also has to know how things were for the majority of people in these countries before socialism, in order to compare.

Well, before the war literacy rate was low and noone had a TV set, the socialist state has come and these things took a fortunate turn ;)

Or if we truly want to put things into perspective, prewar Poland, while obviously poorer than Germany or the UK, was better off than Spain or Portugal (not to mention eg. [South] Korea). A few decades later did young Spaniards dream of picking strawberries in Poland, or was it the other way round?

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by obrero on Sunday August 23, 2015 @05:09PM (#10106750)
> US police is notorious for its brutality, but are these killings ordered by top officials in chain of command?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_of_Fred_Hampton

> If factory workers go on a strike in the US, are police troops sent in to "shoot to kill" them? They did in Poland 30 years ago, eg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacification_of_Wujek

Oh god yes.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockton_cannery_strike_of_193... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Petersburg_sanitation_stri... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auto-Lite_strike#The_.22Battle... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Steel_strike

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by V-2 on Sunday August 23, 2015 @06:07PM (#10106912)
Well, it's hard not to notice that most of these examples happen to be from before the war... closer to the Victorian era than modern times. So that's getting kind of ahistorical.

Secret service functionaries in communist Poland assassinated nearly 100 people in 1980s alone; mainly oppositionists, priests (the most famous father Popiełuszko wasn't the only one), who were unarmed and not affiliated with organized crime.

Furthermore, you wouldn't go to jail for as little as mentioning Fred Hampton (or Wacko siege) in public - let alone trying to write about it... and an anti-government organization such as Black Panther Party, armed and openly denouncing the state, now that's something utterly unthinkable in any "people's republic", they would all get killed. Solidarity was a trade union which formally called for improving socialism.

Don't get me wrong, I am not saying that the US was or is a paradise on Earth, you are obviously right to point out that Eastern bloc did not have a monopoly on political killings or unlawful surveillance.

But to insist that this was ever on par with Soviet-controlled countries in terms of freedom and lawfulness would be a doomed task... you'd quickly start scraping the bottom of the barrel in search of counterexamples; that's sort of like "project Steve" ;)

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by stretchwithme on Sunday August 23, 2015 @04:29PM (#10106652)
Fortunately, there a few of these paradises still available.

Productivity and creativity vary a great deal. It is only fair that compensation varies a great deal too.

We have systems to day that make it possible to deliver value to millions of people. Those who create and make use of those systems are the ones creating that value.

Those who do not don't have some inherent right to what others have produced. But they do get a great many things for a lot less money because of those technologies. And many things that wouldn't exist at all without them.

Which is why even the poor are better off escaping from communism and the foot traffic usually indicates that.

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by coldtea on Sunday August 23, 2015 @07:53PM (#10107244)
>Which is why even the poor are better off escaping from communism and the foot traffic usually indicates that.

The only thing it really indicates is that the soviet states were run badly and have deterioted into dictatorships.

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by mseebach on Monday August 24, 2015 @03:56AM (#10108481)
"Cheka (ЧК – чрезвыча́йная коми́ссия chrezvychaynaya komissiya, Emergency Committee, Russian pronunciation: [tɕɪˈka]) was the first of a succession of Soviet state security organizations. It was created on December 20, 1917, after a decree issued by Vladimir Lenin, and was subsequently led by Felix Dzerzhinsky, a Polish aristocrat turned communist. By late 1918, hundreds of Cheka committees had been created in various cities, at multiple levels including: oblast, guberniya ("Gubcheks"), raion, uyezd, and volost Chekas, with Raion and Volost Extraordinary Commissioners. Many thousands of dissidents, deserters, or other people were arrested, tortured or executed by various Cheka groups. After 1922, Cheka groups underwent a series of reorganizations, with the NKVD, into bodies whose members continued to be referred to as "Chekisty" (Chekists) into the late 1980s.

From its founding, being the military and security arm of the Bolshevik communist party, the Cheka was instrumental in the Red Terror. In 1921 the Troops for the Internal Defense of the Republic (a branch of the Cheka) numbered at least 200,000. These troops policed labor camps; ran the Gulag system; conducted requisitions of food; subjected political opponents to secret arrest, detention, torture and summary execution; and put down rebellions and riots by workers or peasants, and mutinies in the desertion-plagued Red Army."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheka

So, yeah, it "deteriorated into dictatorship" a whole month after the revolution.

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by stretchwithme on Sunday August 30, 2015 @11:27PM (#10145294)
Their plan all along.

Of course, their apologists in the West were doing what they could to help. And still do.

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by hga on Sunday August 23, 2015 @04:42PM (#10106683)
Echoing others, the go-to source for democide tabulates an estimated 10,000 to 54,000 Poles killed by their government in the 1948 to 1987 period.
Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by coldtea on Sunday August 23, 2015 @08:06PM (#10107282)
Can we count blacks, latinos, indians etc killed by cops without a crime in that statistic as well? And even white people, from the Kent State shooting to Wacko?

Or stretch it a little to include kids send to die in wars half a planet away, while young people all over the country were protesting against them?

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by mseebach on Monday August 24, 2015 @04:37AM (#10108567)
OK, let's play.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_killings_by_law_enforc...

1240 is the estimated unusually high number for 2015 and US population is just over 318 million: that's a rate of one in 256,000 (or, 4 per million).

The population of Poland rose from 30 to 38m 1961-1990, so let's assume an even 30m on average for the 39 years covered by the GP. The 10-54k killed in that period come out as 256-1384 pr year, or one in 117,000 to one in 21,000 (or 8-47 per million).

So, even being very generous with the numbers, communist Poland killed its citizens at a rate of twice to more than ten times the rate the US does.

Including military deaths, there has been just over 100k US deaths, WWII to date, that's an average of 1430 to add to the 1240 for 2670/year, or one in 119,000 -- still (just) better than the Polish lower bound.

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by ericd on Sunday August 23, 2015 @05:09PM (#10106747)
I think you're forgetting the other bad things he mentioned - having to wait in line all day for the chance to get some bread, for example.
Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by coldtea on Sunday August 23, 2015 @08:03PM (#10107272)
That was in some special periods -- not all the time. He mentions a special circumstance in the article (don't remember which is it).

But did you note that he went from Netherlands and applied for a job there? Obviously Poland was nowhere near as affluent as the Netherlands, but also obviously he didn't apply for a job in a place were waiting in line for bread was something that happened regularly everyday.

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by blumkvist on Sunday August 23, 2015 @04:33PM (#10106661)
Are you seriously suggesting that people living in the US have it worse than in the communist bloc?
Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by coldtea on Sunday August 23, 2015 @07:58PM (#10107255)
Depends.

There are poor people in the US living in comparable (or worse) conditions than people suffered in some of the countries of the "communist block".

I know some older people from the "block" (from Albania and Hungary for example), and some of them look back into that era as "the good times", considering that they were teachers, engineers and other such jobs, and now they clean floors or poor concrete in construction sites to make a living.

Not to mention that not all places were the same quality of living or freedom-wise. Czechoslovakia for example were in far better condition than Albania or Romania.

Re:A Western Kid Living in Communist Poland (2014) by brc on Sunday August 23, 2015 @11:32PM (#10107760)
No it does not depend at all.

There are people in the USA who have bad outcomes, for sure. But to compare that to soviet-bloc countries is an insult to those who suffered under those totalitarian regimes.

It wasn't just the injustices, the corruption, the shortages or the inability to trust anyone - it was also the fact that there was nothing you personally could do to change or improve the situation.

Poor people in the USA still have freedom of movement, freedom of association, freedom of speech and stores stacked full of cheap food. They also have - no matter how difficult - the ability to change things and improve the lot of themsleves and their families.

Of course there are people who were disadvantaged by a change in the system. And of course that changeover was inequitable. But the improvement at scale for the people as a whole is inarguable.

It always concerns me to see attempts at historical cleansing and ignorance of the horrors of the past.